The Accuracy of Weight Reported in a Web-Based Obesity Treatment Program

Abstract

Objective: The overall goal of the study was to understand the accuracy of self-reported weight over a 6-month Web-based obesity program. Materials and Methods: As part of a larger study, subjects (n = 323; 93% female; 28% African American) were randomized to a 6-month Internet-based behavioral weight loss program with weekly group meetings delivered either: (1) entirely by online synchronous chats or (2) by a combination of online chats plus monthly in-person group sessions. Observed weights were obtained at 0 and 6 months for all participants. Self-reported weights were submitted weekly to the study Web site. Differences in Observed and Reported weights were examined by gender, race, and condition. Results: Observed and Reported weight were significantly correlated at 0 and 6 months (r = 0.996 and 0.996, ps < 0.001 respectively). However, Reported weight underestimated Observed weight by 0.86 kg (p < 0.001) at 6 months. Further, there was a significant weight loss effect (p < 0.001) with those losing more weight more accurately estimating their Reported weight at 6 months. Additionally, 6-month Reported weight change differed from Observed weight change (difference = 0.72 kg, p < 0.001), with weight change using Reported weights estimating a slightly larger weight loss than Observed weights. Conclusions: In general, the accuracy of selfreported weight is high for individuals participating in an Internet-based weight loss treatment program. Accuracy differed slightly by amount of weight lost and was not improved with periodic in-person assessment. Importantly, weight change by self-report was comparable to observed, suggesting that it is suitable for Web-based obesity treatment.

Longitudinal Accuracy of Web-Based Self-Reported Weights: Results From the Hopkins POWER Trial

“…Specifically, participants’ self-report resulted in a modest, yet significant underestimation of weight consistent with previous findings from cross-sectional studies and weight-loss trials [4,5,9,10]. The magnitude of underestimation doubled between Months 6 and 24.…”

Undergrad and Overweight: An Online Behavioral Weight Management Program for College Students

“…However, recent analyses of reported vs observed weights in an online weight loss study found that self-reported and measured weights were significantly correlated. 39 Therefore, the authors feel confident that the weight data are valid. The study was also not a randomized-controlled trial, and therefore causal conclusions cannot be made.…”

Website Usage and Weight Loss in a Free Commercial Online Weight Loss Program: Retrospective Cohort Study

“…The study is also limited by reliance on self-reported weights. However, weight reported by members of another online weight loss program was highly correlated with and similar to objective weights [35]. The lack of date stamps on most website usage variables (except log-ins and weight entries) limited the depth of analysis on the intensity and patterns of website usage.…”