Background Although surgical navigation reduces the rate of malpositioned acetabular cups in total hip arthroplasty (THA), its use has not been widely adopted. As a result of our perceived need for simple and efficient methods of navigation, we developed a mechanical navigation device for acetabular cup orientation. Questions/purposes We assessed accuracy of cup orientation (mean error of cup inclination and anteversion) of a novel mechanical navigation device, percentage of outliers, length of operation, and compared the results with a series of CT-based computer-assisted THAs.Methods Cup orientation of 70 THAs performed using the mechanical navigation device was compared with a historical control group of 146 THAs performed using CT-based computer navigation. Postoperative cup orientation was measured using a validated two-dimensional/ three-dimensional matching method. An outlier was defined outside a range of ± 10°from the planned inclination and/or anteversion. Results Using the mechanical navigation device, we observed a decrease in the errors of inclination (1.3°± 3.4°[ range, Ă6.6°to 8.2°] versus 3.5°± 4.2°[Ă12.7°to 6.9°]), errors of anteversion (1.0°± 4.1°[Ă8.8°to 9.5°] versus 3.0°± 5.8°[Ă11.8°to 19.6°]), percentages of outliers (0% versus 9.6%), and length of operation (112 ± 22 [78-184] minutes versus 132 ± 18 minutes) compared with CT-based navigation. Conclusions Compared with CT-based surgical navigation, navigation of acetabular cup orientation using a mechanical device can be performed in less time, lower mean errors, and minimal equipment.