Terror, Aid and Organization: The Haredi Disaster Victim Identification Teams (ZAKA) in Israel

Abstract

Terror attacks are forms of social and cultural disasters that cause extensive harm to humans and the social order. Yet despite the sudden chaos they wreak and their prevalence during the last decade or so, most societies have only recently created organizational forms that can manage and handle their threatening potential. This article analyzes the relations between terror attacks and the emergence of new organizations specializing in death and disaster. We explore this issue through the case of ZAKA, the Ultra-Orthodox Identification Teams for Victims of Disasters in Israel. This organization sheds light on how in highly complex and bureaucratized countries new types of specialists in death by terror developed. From an anthropological point of view, organizational specialists in death by terror are expected to act proficiently on the basis of existing cultural norms and principles. Such organizational bodies are not only expressions of social responses to the unexpected disorder produced by terror but are also powerful cultural agents that produce new meanings. Concretely, not all organizations gain trust and support from the general public to allow its members to touch, treat and recompose the bodies of the dead, we contend that ZAKA legitimizes its goals and actions through the amalgamation of three unique elements: (a) Given that ZAKA's practices are grounded in Jewish traditions concerning death and burial, the organization use these cultural roots to gain acceptance of treating victims of terror attacks. In this way, the actions of ZAKA volunteers are legitimized since they fulfill central religious (Talmudic) duties concerning death and the treatment of corpses. (b) The organization mixes practices and knowledge from different institutions and bodies such as the police, military or medical organizations. Moreover, ZAKA cooperates with various state organizations that specialize in death events and disasters. This combination not only reinforces the legitimacy of their actions but turns them into social experts for dealing with the victims of terror and mass death. (c) During a terror event the organization deals not only with death but also with aid to, and treatment of, the injured. By giving them social permission to treat, touch and recompose the human flesh, society also sanctions them to touch the very basis of social order: treating the human body and dealing with questions of life and death in the public sphere. We end by offering a number of thoughts about the wider implications of our case study.

On Religiosity and Super-religiosity (I): Measures of Radical Religion

“…This is conducted through an ethnographic study of a particular Haredi institution titled ZAKA (Hebrew acronym for "Disaster Victim Identification"). It is a volunteer organization founded in the 1990s in the wake of a series of Palestinian terror attacks, dedicated to caring for the bodies of the dead after a bombing and ensuring their proper religious burial (Stadler et al 2005). ZAKA leaders and activists are exclusively ultra-Orthodox Jews.…”

On Religiosity and Super-religiosity (II): The Case of Jewish Ultra-orthodoxy

“…In addition, I took part in their special occasions: dancing in holiday celebrations or weddings, violently protesting in mass rallies, attending funerals, taking formal and informal audiences with rabbis, making pilgrimage to saints' tombs and sanctuaries. Especially privileged data is drawn from extensive fieldwork -mostly (participant) observation and in-depth interviewing-of a typically Haredi organization known by its acronym ZaKA (Stadler, Masterman, and Ben-Ari 2005). This organizationalready mentioned in part one -is a volunteer enterprise dedicated to the "sacred mission" of managing the death of the Israeli victims of Palestinian terrorism.…”

Dissection

“…10 Similarly, orthodox Jews in Israel support an organization, Zaka, comprised of religious observant Jews who are trained as forensic volunteers who are called upon to assemble at the scenes of traffic accidents, terrorist attacks, and suicide bombs (Stadler 2005). Family members staged protests while cranes and bulldozers turned up debris that might contain fragments of their loved ones.…”