Abstract. In a recent article [R. R. Alfano and D. A. Nolan, Opt. Commun. 361 (2016) 25] the group velocity reduction below the speed of light in the case of certain Bessel beam pulses has been considered and an idea of its application for a natural optical buffer presented. However, the authors treat the problem as if only one type of Bessel pulse existed, no matter how it is generated. The deficiencies of the article stem from not being familiar with an extensive literature on Bessel pulses, in particular, with a couple of papers published much earlier in the J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, which have studied exactly the same problem more thoroughly. , we see that the implicit premise is that is an independent constant. In the case of a cylindrical waveguide the value of is indeed fixed (for a given mode) by the boundary conditions. But for wave packets in the free 3D space there is no such restriction: is a variable which may take any fixed value, run over a range of values independently or act as a function of or the frequency , (see review [4] and references therein). The restrictive assumption which leads to the subluminal group velocity of Bessel wave packets, has been tacitly made earlier as well, the oldest source we know being a handbook [5]. Out of various other possibilities the simplest is the case where both and are proportional to the frequency or . In this case the wave packet-called the Bessel-X pulse [6]-not only possesses a superluminal group velocity but propagates superluminally as a whole without changing its shape.As to the Bessel light beam considered in [1], in literature it is named the pulsed Bessel beam and not only its subluminal group velocity but also its whole temporal spread and evolution in the course of propagation have been calculated earlier [7][8][9][10][11].