Teaching Cost-Conscious Medicine: Impact of a Simple Educational Intervention on Appropriate Abdominal Imaging at a Community-Based Teaching Hospital

Abstract

Background Rising costs pose a major threat to US health care. Residency programs are being asked to teach residents how to provide cost-conscious medical care. Methods An educational intervention incorporating the American College of Radiology appropriateness criteria with lectures on cost-consciousness and on the actual hospital charges for abdominal imaging was implemented for residents at Scripps Mercy Hospital in San Diego, CA. We hypothesized that residents would order fewer abdominal imaging examinations for patients with complaints of abdominal pain after the intervention. We analyzed the type and number of abdominal imaging studies completed for patients admitted to the inpatient teaching service with primary abdominal complaints for 18 months before (738 patients) and 12 months following the intervention (632 patients). Results There was a significant reduction in mean abdominal computed tomography (CT) scans per patient (1.7–1.4 studies per patient, P < .001) and total abdominal radiology studies per patient (3.1–2.7 studies per patient, P = .02) following the intervention. The avoidance of charges solely due to the reduction in abdominal CT scans following the intervention was $129 per patient or $81,528 in total. Conclusions A simple educational intervention appeared to change the radiologic test-ordering behavior of internal medicine residents. Widespread adoption of similar interventions by residency programs could result in significant savings for the health care system.

Cost awareness among healthcare professionals at a South African hospital: A cross-sectional survey

“…Numerous studies have found that there is no difference in cost estimation accuracy between HCPs at various levels of training and experience, finding no such differences among medical students, residents, faculty physicians, specialists and physicians. [11,14,15] We found that private practice involvement does not significantly influence cost estimation accuracy.…”

A Clinical Process Change and Educational Intervention to Reduce the Use of Unnecessary Preoperative Tests

“…Another study 20 found that a facile cost-consciousness curriculum could alter resident behavior to reduce unnecessary inpatient imaging. Similar to ours, that educational intervention was based on published guidelines, took the form of didactic lectures targeted at residents, and incorporated reminders.…”

Cardiothoracic Imaging Guidelines in Quality Improvement

“…However, an important observation was that 81 of 126 physicians (64%) still indicated that they consult a radiologist as 1 of their top 3 resources, the most popular choice for both residents and attending physicians. 17 Strother et al 18 incorporated a phased quality improvement initiative designed to educate referring clinicians and departmental radiologists about the recommendations of the ACR AC for dual-phase head CT examinations and demonstrated a reduction in the number of dual-phase head CT examinations that were not indicated. 13 In addition, it has been well documented that educational interventions on the use of imaging testing results in improved utilization.…”