Tax Reforms and Intertemporal Shifting of Wage Income: Evidence from Danish Monthly Payroll Records

Abstract

Tax Reforms and Intertemporal Shifting of Wage Income: Evidence from Danish Monthly Payroll Records* Intertemporal shifting of wage income takes place when income earned in one tax year is paid out in another tax year in order to save taxes. Shifting has implications for the evaluation of the distortionary and distributional effects of taxes and may cause serious bias in empirical estimates of the elasticity of taxable income (ETI) for use in policy analysis. Based on new monthly payroll records for the universe of Danish employees we provide evidence of widespread intertemporal shifting of wage income in response to a tax reform that significantly reduced the marginal tax rates for 1/4 of all employees. Ignoring shifting, we estimate the overall ETI to be 0.1 and find that the ETI is increasing in the earnings level. After controlling for shifting, we obtain negligible ETI estimates at all earnings levels. We show that shifting is concentrated on few individuals spread out evenly across industry sectors, and we provide evidence suggesting that tax salience, liquidity constraints and firm willingness to cooperate in shifting are important factors in explaining shifting behavior.JEL Classification: H24 and H31

Taking the high road? Compliance with commuter tax allowances and the role of evasion spillovers

“…These reporting responses indicate that employees are aware of the allowance scheme' structure and shows the importance of proximity to the next higher bracket for the evasion decision. This pattern is also in accordance with recent evidence suggesting strong behavioral responses ('bunching') at salient discontinuities of the tax code (see, e.g., Saez 2010, Chetty et al 2011, Kleven and Waseem 2013, and Kreiner, Leth-Petersen and Skov 2014. Further, the solid line in Figure 2 displays the total number of cheaters in each bin (right scale of the figure).…”

The elasticity of taxable income in the presence of deduction possibilities

“…One reason for differences could be households changing the timing of income realizations (Kreiner et al 2013) or bringing forward or postponing deductions from one year to the next due to changing tax rates, regardless of any "real"…”

“…Other channels that have been found to contribute to the ETI are, e.g., inter-and intra-temporal income shifting (Auerbach and Slemrod 1997, Kreiner et al 2013, Harju and Matikka 2013, le Maire and Schjerning 2013, Kreiner et al 2014, or tax non-compliance (Gorodnichenko et al 2009;Kleven et al 2011). …”

The Elasticity of Taxable Income: A Meta-Regression Analysis

“…Much of the evidence is based on self-employed and/or high-income taxpayers given their larger range of opportunities to adjust their (taxable or gross) income (e.g. Kreiner et al (2014Kreiner et al ( , 2016, Le Maire and Schjerning (2013) or Harju and Matikka (2016)). Kleven et al (2011) and Kleven et al (2016) stress that third party information reporting influences the magnitude of behavioral responses.…”