Syrian refugees in digital news discourse: Depictions and reflections in Germany

Abstract

This study examines the topical frames reflected in articles published about Syrian refugees by German, British and American news websites in 2016. We analyze these for terms associated with Syrian refugees and the themes they address then relate them to those we identified for 2015 and to those indicated by German students in expressing their attitudes towards them. The results show that, despite discrepancies in the occurrence of Syrian refugees’ collocates in our 2016 news corpora, they still reflect, at a lower rate, the themes identified for 2015: humanitarianism, conflict, dehumanization, security, economic burden, political responsibility, and integration. The survey results confirm humanitarianism and integration as particularly prominent themes for our participants, too. While our findings provide further discursive evidence for the variation in refugees’ representations in news discourse and for the influence of media on public opinion, they suggest that this impact may be balanced out by other factors including an audience’s critical reading and thinking skills.

The political economy of bordering and the reproduction of borders in the case of Frontex

“…In different EU countries, stereotypical frames of migrants dominate before, during, and after the “crisis” of 2015. Negative framings of migrants as threats are accompanied by humanitarian pity (Greussing and Boomgaarden, 2017; Mustafa-Awad and Kirner-Ludwig, 2021; Siapera, 2019). Krzyżanowski argues that racism toward refugees in Poland existed before 2015, and was simply normalized within a general rise of right-wing politics (2020).…”

Afghan Refugees in Pakistani English Dailies: In Context of Peace Journalism

“…2017). Mainstream and social media more frequently framed immigrants as a financial, security, and cultural threat to the host country (Conzo, et, al, 2021;Mustafa, 2021). Diversified social media apps used biased and prejudiced expressions for immigrants (Bosco,2017) Public perception and views about a certain group are associated with media treatment and framing of that particular group.…”

Critical analysis of dehumanizing news photographs on immigrants: Examples of the portrayal of non-citizenship

“…Other studies focus on the way refugees are represented and how the reality of the human beings portrayed is renegotiated through the different multimodal resources (Mielczarek, 2020; Mustafa-Awad and Kirner-Ludwig, 2021; Özdora Akşak, 2019). These studies reinforce the rhetorical powers of images and their importance in influencing the audience’s ideology while associating refugees with humanitarianism, conflict, dehumanization, security, economic burden, political responsibility and integration, among others.…”