“…Nonmetal doping or codoping into the TiO 2 modifies the valence band level of TiO 2 , reducing the effective band gap energy, as shown in Figure 1, and modulating the light absorption into the visible light region [25,26,27,28,29,30]. Although the incorporation of dopant elements can result in the advantage of narrowing band gap energies, dopants can influence charge carrier recombination processes, and the limited solubility of dopants into the bulk materials as well as thermal instability have limited photocatalytic applications of doped TiO 2 materials [31,32,33,34,35].…”