Substitution or complementarity: why do rice farmers use a mix of biopesticides and chemical pesticides in China?

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Although scholars have become increasingly concerned about finding ways to encourage more farmers to use biopesticides and fewer to use chemical pesticides, few studies have investigated the prevalence of Chinese rice farmers' mixed use of biopesticides and chemical pesticides for pest management.RESULTS: Based on a household survey in Hubei Province, China, this study found that 59.18% of the sample rice farmers used a mix of biopesticides and chemical pesticides. There is mainly a complementarity relationship between rice farmers' decision to use biopesticides and chemical pesticides. The pursuit of multiple production purposes is the main reason why farmers decide on the mixed-use of pesticides. Specifically, farmers generally tend to use biopesticides to ensure food safety for consumption, and chemical pesticides to reduce costs for profitability. The decision of farmers to mix pesticides has led to an increase of pesticide varieties and costs. However, it reduces the frequency of pesticide use, and does not result in a significant increase in rice yield and output value.CONCLUSION: While food safety should be emphasized in working towards greater use of biopesticides, rice farmers' mixed use of biopesticides and chemical pesticides will remain for a long time until the biotechnology is more developed. In fact, programs that investigate the effects of a combination of biopesticides and chemical pesticides should be implemented to achieve pesticide reduction, because biopesticides and chemical pesticides have specific disadvantages.

Herbicide use in conventional cereal production in northern Greece: An appraisal through the theory of planned behavior

“…For example, it has been shown that farmers make decisions by pursuing multiple production purposes, e.g. use biopesticides to ensure food safety for consumption and chemical pesticides to reduce costs for profitability, 64 or by showing strong motivations beyond the economic benefit, e.g. adopt biological control for reasons of health maintenance and environmental protection 65 …”

Indole‐3‐acetonitrile Is a Critical Molecule with Weed Allopathic Suppression Function in Broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica)

“…Most plants produce abundant allelopathic compounds that can effectively suppress weed seed germination and growth, minimizing the use of synthetic herbicides. [5,6] Brassicaceae, known as the cabbage or mustard family, is a group of plants with strong allelopathy. [7] The allelopathic effects of these plants have long been reported; in 1985, Willis showed that cabbage inhibits grape growth.…”

The dual impacts of specialized agricultural services on pesticide application intensity: Evidence from China

“…Pesticide application has played a positive role in controlling crop diseases and pests and in increasing crop yield. [1][2][3] For example, the global grain loss recovered by pesticide application accounted for 15% of the total grain output. 4 However, pesticides function as a double-edged sword.…”

“…Due to changes in climate and cultivation patterns, crop diseases and insect pests have intensified a trend of frequent and repetitive occurrences, posing a great threat to agricultural production and food security. Pesticide application has played a positive role in controlling crop diseases and pests and in increasing crop yield 1–3 . For example, the global grain loss recovered by pesticide application accounted for 15% of the total grain output 4 .…”