Subnational Politics in Spain: New Avenues for Feminist Policymaking and Activism

Abstract

In this article, I evaluate how subnational governments pursue feminist policy outputs. To do so, I examine equality policies in the Spanish regions of Andalusia and Galicia during the 1980s and 1990s. Whereas the national Women's Institute in Spain was the driving force behind equality policies during the 1980s, regional administrations gained autonomy in the early 1980s and developed their own equality policies during the 1990s and 2000s. I ask 1) whether leftist political allies are key to feminist policy outputs, 2) whether regional feminist policy outputs increase over time as subnational institutions develop, and 3) whether feminists in society are able to impact such policies. I conclude that subnational administrations do not always advance feminist policy outputs nor do they work cooperatively with all feminist organizations. Whereas the leftist regional administration of Andalusia has been a leader in feminist policymaking, the conservative Galician administration developed equality policies more slowly, and these policies were controversial among feminists and leftist politicians. I explain how regional women's policy agencies led by the Left and Right have nevertheless promoted women's civil society and policies that respond to women's local identities.

Do Women Represent Women in France? The Case of Brittany's Regional Council

“…to a greater extent than those on the Right (e.g. Lovenduski and Norris, 1993;Ortbals, 2008). My interviews with council members echoed this scholarly literature.…”

Políticas de salud sexual y reproductiva en España: Contra-movimientos y marcos interpretativos en conflicto

“…Diversas investigaciones muestran que su desarrollo ha estado fuertemente condicionado por el color político del gobierno de la Xunta, pudiendo diferenciarse claramente tres etapas, que influyeron también de forma clara en las políticas autonómicas en materia de salud sexual y reproductiva (Ortbals, 2008;Diz y Lois, 2011.…”

“…Sin embargo, se constatan diferencias importantes en relación a otras autonomías gobernadas por partidos de centro-izquierda -como, por ejemplo, Andalucía-, relacionadas fundamentalmente con el fuerte distanciamiento de las políticas gallegas de las demandas feministas. Así, durante esta etapa, estas actuaciones estuvieron en buena medida vinculadas a las políticas familiares 10 y a través de las mismas, se promovió el papel tradicional de las mujeres como madres y cuidadoras, por encima de cualquier otra identidad o rol que éstas quisieran desarrollar (Ortbals, 2008). El movimiento feminista gallego fue crítico con el SGI y las políticas que puso en marcha desde su creación, refiriéndose incluso a la década de 1990 como los "años de la ofensiva patriarcal" (Ortbals, 2007).…”

Three Decades of State Feminism and Gender Equality Policies in Multi-governed Spain

“…Indeed, there are several Spanish women's movements that are not necessarily feminist; they may be composed of widows, housewives, or "cultural" associations, for example. This fragmentation is also territorial, with each region expressing different dynamics of women's and feminist movements (Bustelo and Ortbals 2007, p. 215;Ortbals 2007Ortbals , 2008.…”