Subjective variables in travel behavior models: a critical review and Standardized Transport Attitude Measurement Protocol (STAMP)

Abstract

Understanding people's travel behavior is necessary for achieving goals such as increased bicycling and walking, decreased traffic congestion, and adoption of clean-fuel vehicles. To understand underlying motivations, researchers increasingly are adding subjective variables to models of travel behavior. This article presents a systematic review of 158 such studies. Nearly every reviewed article finds subjective variables to be predictive of transport outcomes. However, the 158 reviewed studies include 2864 distinct subjective survey questions. This heterogeneity makes it difficult to reach definitive conclusions about which subjective variables are most important for which transport outcomes. In addition to heterogeneity, challenges of this literature also include an unclear direction of causality and tautological relationships between some subjective variables and behavior. Within the constraints imposed by these challenges, we attempt to evaluate the explanatory power of subjective variables, which subjective variables matter most for which transport choices, and whether the answers to these questions vary between continents. To reduce heterogeneity in future studies, we introduce the Standardized Transport Attitude Measurement Protocol, which identifies a curated set of subjective questions. We have also developed an open-access database of the reviewed studies, including all subjective survey questions and models, with an interactive, searchable interface. Keywords Attitudes • Perceptions • Travel choice • Travel behavior • Factor analysisNathan Harness and Alexis Consalvo have contributed equally.

Studying the Joint Effects of Perceived Service Quality, Perceived Benefits, and Environmental Concerns in Sustainable Travel Behavior: Extending the TPB

“…Perceived behavioral control refers to a person's assessment of his/her own effectiveness and perceived controllability in engaging in a behavior [51,145]. It is, therefore, broadly considered one of the most-important elements affecting individual behaviors [22,25,141,146]. Thus, in this study, we found that perceived behavioral control was significantly associated with the intention to continue to use the Metro.…”

“…Finally, even though sustainable traveling modes are gradually attracting increased attention in academia [17,[21][22][23][24][25][26][27], due to its importance in facing the issue of climate changes, most of the studies in this context have focused on developed countries, while neglecting developing countries. Therefore, this study is among the few studies that attempts to examine some critical factors that may significantly impact the intention to continue using sustainable traveling modes, particularly in the context of the MENA region.…”

Exploring Subjective Attitudes Towards Public Transport of Intercity Travel and Their Relationships

“…Attitude plays an important role in travel decision-making and therefore has a significant impact on travel behavior (Lättman et al, 2019). Recent research shows that attitudes have a greater impact on travel decisions than other variables such as socio-demographic or built environment factors (Bhagat Conway et al, 2024). The subjective perception and evaluation of the transportation system by travelers are also the basis for measuring and further improving transportation services.…”

The association of travel burden with prenatal care utilization, what happens after provider-selection

“…(17,18) Recent studies have shown that subjective opinions related to transportation can also in uence people's travel behavior and their assessment of travel burdens. (19,20) Previous studies have shown that the high-risk population perceive a greater transportation burden compared to their counterparts. (21) In these studies, the measures of perceived travel burden encompass not only transportation expenses and accessibility but also safety concerns and opportunities.…”