Structure-dynamic relationship of plant–insect networks along a primary succession gradient on a glacier foreland

Abstract

There is a growing interest in understanding the structure-dynamic relationship of ecological networks. Ecological network changes along primary successions are poorly known: to address such topic, gradient of primary succession on glacier forelands is an ideal model, as sites of different age since deglaciation stand for different ecosystem developmental stages. We aimed to investigate the assembly processes of plant-insect networks and to elucidate its functional implications for ecosystem stability along this time sequence succession. We collected data on the functional role of anthophilous insect groups and performed network analysis to evaluate their relative importance in the structure of plant-insect interaction networks with increasing time since deglaciation along the primary succession of a debriscovered glacier foreland. We sampled anthophilous insects visiting the flowers of two models plant species, Leucanthemopsis alpina and Saxifraga bryoides. Insects were identified and trophic roles were attributed to each taxon (detritivores, parasitoids, phytophagous, pollinators, predators, and opportunists) at five sites representing the primary succession gradient. Plant-insect interactions were visually represented by a bipartite network for each successional stage. For each plant species and insect group, centrality indices were computed quantifying their community importance. For the whole network, centralization and link density were calculated. Pollinators dominated pioneer communities on the debris-covered glacier and in recently deglaciated areas, while parasitoids, predators and opportunists characterised late-succession stages. Plant species centrality varied along the succession. Pollinators showed initially higher but then decreasing centrality, while the centrality of predators and parasitoids increased with time since deglaciation. Along the same gradient link density showed an increasing trend while network centralization tended to decrease. The present study provides new insight into the initial steps of plantinsect network assembly and sheds light on the relationship between structure and dynamic in ecological networks. In particular, during the succession process, more links are formed and plant-anthophilous insect interactions change from a network dominated by pollinators to a functionally more diversified food web. We conclude that applying network theory to the study of primary succession provides a useful framework to investigate the relationship between community structure and ecosystem stability. higher but then decreasing centrality, while the centrality of predators and parasitoids increased with time since deglaciation. Along the same gradient link density showed an increasing trend while network centralization tended to decrease. The present study provides new insight into the initial steps of plant-insect network assembly and sheds light on the relationship between structure and dynamic in ecological networks. In particular, during the succession process, more links ar...

The vulnerability of plant-pollinator communities to honeybee decline: A comparative network analysis in different habitat types

“…Further, aggregating species into larger functional groups would be a probably interesting research direction (aggregation based on either traits or network topology; Garibaldi et al, 2015), while some patterns at the network level can be better understood in the light of metrics analysed at the species level (Soares et al, 2017;Kovács-Hostyánszki et al, in prep). It should be also important to merge plant-pollinator interactions with others in unified models (see Losapio et al, 2015). As of particular interest, both from a network dynamics point of view and also biologically, we have to better understand dwarf components: why are these species not connected to the giant component and how could they be connected (though which other species)?…”

Perspectives for ecological networks in plant ecology

“…Nestedness of plant facilitation networks has been proposed to be also responsible for driving ecological succession as networks become more nested with increasing successional age (Losapio et al 2018a). This suggests that the stability of ecological networks against species loss increases throughout ecological successions, as also evidenced by plant-insect network dynamics (Losapio et al 2015). Results from tropical forests (Marcilio-Silva et al 2015) also highlight the importance of species turnover over the influence of some species traits related to dispersal and canopy size.…”

Soil Microbial Networks Shift Across a High-Elevation Successional Gradient

“…Studies of macroorganisms generally find that interaction networks increase in complexity across succession. In pollination biology (Albrecht et al, 2010;Losapio et al, 2015) and work on animal food webs (Wardle et al, 1995;Neutel et al, 2007), network complexity (typically measured as the number of connections per species) increases due to the increase in quantity and diversity of resources over succession. Experiments have also shown that substrate limitation can constrain the complexity of animal food webs (Chen and Wise, 1999).…”