Stress echocardiography and the human factor: The importance of being expert

Abstract

The aim of this study was to evaluate how the diagnostic accuracy of a stress echocardiographic procedure, such as a dipyridamole echocardiography test, depends on the specific experience of the physician interpreting the test. Recordings of 50 consecutive dipyridamole echocardiographic tests were selected for the first part of the study. They were analyzed by 20 experienced echocardiographers with different backgrounds in stress echocardiography: 10 beginners (less than 20 stress studies interpreted with trained staff) and 10 experienced observers (greater than or equal to 100 stress studies performed). Diagnostic accuracy (true positive + true negative/total number of tests) versus the angiographic reference standard (greater than 70% coronary stenosis of at least one major coronary artery) was 62 +/- 6% for beginners and 85 +/- 3% for experienced observers (p less than 0.0001). In the second part of the study, 10 observers (5 beginners and 5 experienced observers) evaluated 2 different sets of 50 dipyridamole echocardiographic test studies before and after the training of the beginners. Before training, the accuracy of beginners was lower than that of experienced observers (61 +/- 7% versus 85 +/- 3%; p less than 0.001). After training, the accuracy gap was closed (83 +/- 3% versus 86 +/- 2%; p = NS). Therefore, interpretation of stress echocardiographic tests by an echocardiographer without specific training severely underestimates the diagnostic potential of this technique. One hundred stress echocardiographic studies are more than adequate to build the individual learning curve and reach the plateau of diagnostic accuracy that the test can yield.

Combined Assessment of Myocardial Perfusion and Regional Left Ventricular Function by Analysis of Contrast-Enhanced Power Modulation Images

“…14,15 The sensitivity of this methodology is limited, because even severe stenosis may not cause a wall motion abnormality at rest. Accordingly, there is a strong need for techniques capable of extracting more information from ultrasound images that may provide additional insights into myocardial physiology.…”

Prediction of Outcomes in Hypertensive Patients With Suspected Coronary Disease

“…9 Resting left ventricular function was qualitatively evaluated by an experienced observer as normal, mild, moderately, or severely reduced, based on assessment of the extent of abnormal wall motion. Stress echocardiograms were interpreted by comparison of rest and stress images using the quad-screen digital display, with review of video-tape if desired.…”

The additive prognostic value of restrictive pattern and dipyridamole‐induced contractile reserve in idiopathic dilated cardiomyopathy

“…First, central laboratory examination of stress echocardiograms was not available; therefore, interinstitutional variability in interpretation affects the results. However, interobserver agreement is substantially higher when explicit reading criteria, similar to those adopted in the current study, are used [38]. In addition, each interpreting cardiologist met quality control criteria before entering the study.…”