State Aid and Export Competitiveness in the EU

Abstract

Despite the proclaimed return of industrial policy (Wade, 2012) state aid provided by EU Member States remains at a historically low level. This is partly explained by the unique institutional arrangement in the EU which empowers the European Commission to monitor and restrict state aid activities of Member States. Making use of European state aid statistics over the period 1995-2011 we employ an augmented macroeconomic export function to investigate the relationship between state aid for the manufacturing sector and Member States' export performance. With manufacturing value added exports serving as a proxy for export performance, our model suggests that a 10% increase in manufacturing aid increases exports by 0.67% for the average EU country. The result is confirmed by instrumental variable estimation. We also find that the impact of state aid on exports is increasing with government effectiveness leading to large differences in the leverage of aid expenditures to promote export performance across Member States.

Innovation, Competition and Productivity: Firm Level Evidence for Eastern Europe and Central Asia

“…While in practice each case needs to be looked at in detail, some general conclusions emerge, if we deliberately condition our considerations on the initial intensity of competition in the market: -Cases in antitrust and merger control typically are subject to closer investigation only when there already is reason to suspect a low level of initial competition. As a general rule, we should hence find most cases in the upward sloping part of the inverted-U, and expect that innovation also benefits from a strict application to maintain a high 22 See, e.g., Rodrik (2008), Farla (2015), or Stoellinger and Holzner (2016).…”

Innovation, competition and productivity

“…If we understand development as the combination of growth and qualitative transformations (Schumpeter, 1947), policy must seek dialogue with the stakeholders in place, who have expertise about the specific industrial structures and institutions that shape the formation of competitive advantages. 23 Because of the asymmetric distribution of information, however, such a dialogue also 23 See, e.g., Rodrik (2008), Farla (2015) or Stoellinger and Holzner (2016). Interestingly, it is the nonlinear nature of the inverted-U hypothesis that can resolve much of the mystery also for policy-making.…”

The Effects of State Aid on Export Performance: EU15 and Turkey

“…In estimating the empirical relationship between state aid for export and export performance in EU-15 and Turkey, Görg et al (2005), Wilkison and Brouthers (2006), Martincus and Carballo (2010), Aghion et al (2011), Jalali (2012, Buts and Jegers (2013) and Stöllinger and Holzner (2013) was used. The functional form of the model is specified below in Eq.…”