Standing Out in Canada and Japan

Abstract

The need for separation or individuation is held to be a prime motive in Western psychology. Varied accounts of the meaning of selfhood in Japan indicate that separation may be much less importantor as important-for understanding the construction of self-identity in that culture. We focus here on personal distinctiveness, one vehicle for separation from others. We propose that the desire for distinctiveness is not absent or negligible in Japan, but is subject to more constrained expression than in the West. The results of two studies comparing Japanese and Canadian students suggest that Japanese are less desirous of standing out for their own sake and more likely to experience this form of distinctiveness as aversive. The results also suggest that although Japanese and Canadians derive positive distinctiveness from much the same sources, Japanese are less gratified by this type of experience.Since antiquity, social motivation has been understood as a dialectic of separation and attachment. In Plato's Symposium, Aristophanes recounts how Zeus punished primeval humans by splitting them into separate halves. The result was love, a yearning for completion by

Just Another Face in the Crowd? Distinctiveness Seeking in Sweden and Britain

“…Burns and Brady (1992) found significantly lower overall need for uniqueness scores among Malaysian than US business students; however, this difference was specific to a subscale of "lack of concern for others", suggesting a cultural difference in concern for social acceptance, rather than in the desire for uniqueness itself. Tafarodi et al (2004) found no difference between Japanese and Canadian undergraduates in overall need for uniqueness scores, although Japanese participants scored lower on items reflecting "desire to be different".…”

Power moderates the impact of desire for exclusivity on luxury experiential consumption

“…Recent consumer research demonstrates that consumers adopt different types of differentiation strategies (Chan, Berger, & Boven, 2012;Dommer, Swaminathan, & Ahluwalia, 2013), namely, horizontal and vertical differentiation (Tafarodi, Marshall, & Katsura, 2004). Horizontal differentiation represents attaining distinction from others based on personality, taste, and so on, whereas vertical differentiation implies achieving distinction from others by signaling one's superiority to others or status (Dommer et al, 2013;Tafarodi et al, 2004). Differentiation driven by the desire for exclusivity resembles vertical differentiation, whereas differentiation driven by the need for uniqueness can be said to be in line with horizontal differentiation.…”

Learning the Confucian Way

“…Collectivism prevails in CHC contexts, such as in Mainland China, Hong Kong, Japan, Korea, Singapore, and elsewhere. This concept is expressed by the old Japanese proverb, “The nail that stands out gets pounded down.” In collectivist cultures, people avoid standing out from their groups because it may result in conflict and jeopardize group harmony (Tafarodi, Marshall, and Katsura ). Thus, in a collectivist classroom, students are reluctant to speak up without the sanction of the group or invitation from the teacher (Carless ).…”