Spatial Distortion in MRI-Guided Stereotactic Procedures: Evaluation in 1.5-, 3- and 7-Tesla MRI Scanners

Abstract

Background: Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is replacing computed tomography (CT) as the main imaging modality for stereotactic transformations. MRI is prone to spatial distortion artifacts, which can lead to inaccuracy in stereotactic procedures. Objective: Modern MRI systems provide distortion correction algorithms that may ameliorate this problem. This study investigates the different options of distortion correction using standard 1.5-, 3- and 7-tesla MRI scanners. Methods: A phantom was mounted on a stereotactic frame. One CT scan and three MRI scans were performed. At all three field strengths, two 3-dimensional sequences, volumetric interpolated breath-hold examination (VIBE) and magnetization-prepared rapid acquisition with gradient echo, were acquired, and automatic distortion correction was performed. Global stereotactic transformation of all 13 datasets was performed and two stereotactic planning workflows (MRI only vs. CT/MR image fusion) were subsequently analysed. Results: Distortion correction on the 1.5- and 3-tesla scanners caused a considerable reduction in positional error. The effect was more pronounced when using the VIBE sequences. By using co-registration (CT/MR image fusion), even a lower positional error could be obtained. In ultra-high-field (7 T) MR imaging, distortion correction introduced even higher errors. However, the accuracy of non-corrected 7-tesla sequences was comparable to CT/MR image fusion 3-tesla imaging. Conclusion: MRI distortion correction algorithms can reduce positional errors by up to 60%. For stereotactic applications of utmost precision, we recommend a co-registration to an additional CT dataset.

A novel re-attachable stereotactic frame for MRI-guided neuronavigation and its validation in a large animal and human cadaver model

“…However, the surgical procedure itself has remained relatively unchanged since its inception over thirty years ago (Benabid et al 1987, Sironi 2011). Although the surgical procedure varies from institution to institution, its success depends on the accurate placement of DBS electrodes into targeted brain structures, supported by precision stereotactic devices (Nakazawa et al 2014, Neumann et al 2015, Seibert et al 2016). The gold-standard traditional stereotactic system- the Leksell™ (Elekta, Stockholm, Sweden)- achieves this precision through a rigid head frame that remains affixed throughout the surgical planning and electrode placement to preserve the precision of the stereotactic coordinate space as mapped to the patient’s anatomy through MR images.…”

Stereotactic radiosurgery planning of vestibular schwannomas: IsMRIat 3 Tesla geometrically accurate?

“…The spatial dependence of gradient fields is mainly determined by the design of the gradient coils and is expected to be effectively corrected by the general image post‐processing provided by the MRI manufacturer. Although strictly speaking this issue needs to be revisited for each MRI system, in our experience the main MRI manufacturers use similar technology and the provided correction for gradient non‐uniformity achieves similar results around the isocenter; the literature confirms that system‐related distortions are clinically acceptable at 3.0 T and at 7.0 T in a wide variety of clinical systems. Studies considering longitudinal changes in geometrical distortion in general suggest stability of the distortion pattern .…”

“…Considering the skull, there is widespread consensus in the literature that susceptibility‐induced displacements are most relevant in the vicinity of airspaces, and are emphasized at higher field strength . Duchin et al.…”

“…Considering the skull, there is widespread consensus in the literature that susceptibility-induced displacements are most relevant in the vicinity of airspaces, and are emphasized at higher field strength. [17][18][19][20][21] Duchin et al used transformation matrixes from MR-CT co-registration to assess the level of distortion, and only found sub-millimeter errors. 19 Wang et al mapped magnetic field from the top of the head to the bottom of the cerebellum, confirming higher field inhomogeneity surrounding air spaces.…”

Magnetic resonance imaging for brain stereotactic radiotherapy

“…As MR-CT registration has been shown to reduce positional errors introduced by MRI, minimization of MR distortions becomes even more relevant, when opting for an MR-only workflow [29].…”