Space invaders: The moral‐spatial order in neighbour dispute discourse

Abstract

This paper investigates the interactional construction of neighbour relationships in the context of disputational talk. Neighbour dispute data were recorded in two contexts: community mediation and televised documentaries. The data were transcribed and subsequently analysed using an approach that combined ethnomethodological methods with discursive psychology, focusing on participants' orientations to and constructions of spatial categories and place formulations. Three broad themes emerged from our analysis. First, we found that the construction and regulation of normative neighbour relationships were formulated in a discourse of spatial practice. Second, we found that, through complaints about spatial transgressions and 'good' and 'bad' neighbours, the moral order was reproduced and maintained. Finally, we found that, although participants were oriented to a distinction between 'private' and 'public' spaces, talk about boundaries revealed the highly contingent nature of spatial division. We suggest that in order to better understand neighbour relationships, social psychologists must explore the way people construct and account for the spaces they interact within.

On the contested nature of place: ‘Figuera’s Well’, ‘The Hole of Shame’ and the ideological struggle over public space in Barcelona

“…Moreover, they investigate not only how such practices underpin individuals' 'sense of place', but also how they are designed to perform a range of other social and political actions within a given context. Constructions of place or of the nature of person-place bonds, for instance, may be designed to warrant resistance to the process of racial desegregation (Dixon & Durrheim, 2004), condemn others' behaviour as a 'breech' of legitimate boundaries between neighbours (Stokoe & Wallwork, 2003), or manage external threats to place identity (Hugh-Jones & Madill, 2009). …”

Revisiting the potential of community empowerment within UK neighbourhood policing meetings

“…Our interviews with those who felt excluded identified these divisive elements, with the residents of all the PACT meetings being mainly over 50, white, and long standing members of their communities. They constructed themselves as the 'faithful', similar to Stokoe and Wallwork's (2003) 'good citizens' and in contrast to the 'other' in the community and to less worthy citizens (Hughes 2007, Huey & Quirouette 2010.…”

Will There Be a Place for my Life?: Cities, Subjectivities and Geographies of Resistance

“…On the other hand, studies in urban sociology and in discursive social and environmental psychology (Aiello & Bonaiuto, 2003;Di Masso, 2007;Dixon, 2001;Dixon & Durrheim, 2000;Stokoe & Wallwork, 2003;Wacquant, 2007) have provided interesting accounts of how people use spatial significations and metaphors discursively to regulate social relations and notions of place-identity.…”