Socially Not Acceptable: Lessons from a Wind Farm Project in St-Valentin, Quebec

Abstract

Social acceptability appears as a new public norm that major projects must meet in order to be authorized and realized. This article proposes to analyze the case of a wind farm project in the municipality of St-Valentin, Quebec, Canada near the border with Vermont, which was cancelled by the government due to lack of social acceptance, in order to illustrate the importance of this norm today. The project involved the construction of 25 turbines to generate 52 MW of power. Launched in 2006, the project was already significantly under way by 2008; however, in 2011, the government permanently shelved it. Through a combination of document analysis and 11 interviews, we identified the main reasons for the lack of social acceptability: lack of upstream consultation from the developer and wrong scale planned for the consultation process, controversies surrounding the public decision-making process, profound contradictions between the community’s values and interests and the nature of the project, and perceptions of the impacts on the landscape and conflicting uses. For better project social acceptability, lessons learned from this case suggest from a procedural perspective opting for broad, open, and early consultation, prioritizing a regional scale for the approach and acting with transparency, clear rules and a concern for building an ongoing relationship with stakeholders. From a more substantive perspective, our analysis points to the importance of factoring in the level of compatibility between the nature of the project and the values and interests shared by stakeholders in the community, and planning potential modifications to adapt the project to the context in light of their demands.

Connections Between Wind Energy, Poverty and Social Sustainability in Brazil’s Semiarid

“…In this way, the qualitative analysis of the population's well-being will become relevant [65]. It is important that, in Brazil, wind projects accompany the successful experiences registered worldwide, such as Quebec (Canada), where compatibilization of community interests and social acceptance are considered for the construction of wind farms [66]. India, interested in the development and concerned about the current pace of the demographic explosion, intends to achieve a technical-economic balance with an emphasis on environmental sustainability.…”

“Do you Know What's Underneath your Feet?”: Underground Landscapes & Place‐Based Risk Perceptions of Proposed Shale Gas Sites in Rural British Communities☆

“…Precisely what options are pursued to reduce carbon emissions and meet global demand depends in part on public perceptions about different energy sources and practices where new projects are proposed (Viklund 2004). Risk perceptions can influence public support or opposition to different types of energy projects (Tan et al 2022) which can, in turn, influence whether a proposed energy project moves forward (Heagle, Naterer, and Pope 2011; Mulvihill, Winfield, and Etcheverry 2013; Shaw et al 2015; Simard 2018). While traditionally public concerns about energy‐related risks have been focused on aboveground processes, more recently an emphasis on subsurface risks (e.g.…”