Social Life as Bootstrapped Induction

Abstract

How people refer and how they infer are key empirical questions for the sociology of knowledge. In the present paper, I suggest that in the course of social interaction much referring activity is self-referring, and much inference self-validating. This occurs to the extent that our inductive inferences become permeated with feedback-loops or `bootstraps': I offer a simple general form of representation to assist in thinking about bootstrapped induction. In the second half of the paper I indicate some of the interesting consequences of the existence of bootstrapped induction: I cite the self-fulfilling prophesy as a special case where the induction is destructive, but emphasize the role of bootstrapped induction in constituting stable institutional forms. Finally I raise the question as to how far the bootstraps can be eliminated from patterns of inference: I suggest that this problem might be best attacked by sociologists of natural science.

Repressed Futures: Financial Derivatives’ Theological Unconscious

“…He demonstrates that it was the Black-Scholes formula itself that conjured forth a world after its own image, rather than naming a naturally occurring world of nance 'out there' in advance of the formulation. MacKenzie is leaning on Barnes (1983) and Austin (1962), the latter of which also in uences the linguistic anthropology I draw on here. I would like to thank Hiro Miyazaki for drawing my attention to MacKenzie's important paper, the only critical analysis of derivatives I have seen that actually attends in a sustained fashion to the problem of mathematical technique.…”

A tese de performatividade e o ambiente das ideias: o papel dos modelos formais em economia

“…No entanto, parece sustentar uma postura conservadora e convencional sobre a ciência econômica quando diz que a formação 5 Em alusão ao sociólogo Barry Barnes (1983Barnes ( , 1988, orientador de Donald MacKenzie, que enfatizou o papel central na vida social de self-validating feedback loops. Se um monarca absoluto designa Robin Hood um "fora da lei", então Robin é um fora da lei.…”

The material production of virtuality: innovation, cultural geography and facticity in derivatives markets

“…LIBOR is of course a social-kind (Barnes 1983), performative fact: it is the output of the above process. The one significant issue about its facticity has concerned not the integrity of the process but its output's representativeness.…”