The racial ideology of colour-blind racism has made contemporary racism discreet through the dominant group's (i.e., White individuals) ignorance of race. Its expressions can be especially concerning within the legal system, and specifically among juries, given tendencies for jurisdictions to use predominantly White jurors (Abdigir et al., 2018), and the disproportionate representation of Black and Indigenous peoples in Canadian prisons (Office of the Correctional Investigator, 2019;2021). A total of 22 mixed-race and 14 all-White mock jury deliberations examining a Black or Indigenous defendant were analyzed through a qualitative discourse analysis. Results revealed that colour-blind racism was expressed toward both defendants, with slightly more expressions towards Indigenous defendants through more dismissals of racial issues, negative non-racial descriptors of the defendant, or a total absence of race mentions. This study can inform the ways that this racial ideology is expressed in contemporary Canada despite national narratives of multiculturalism and inclusion.