Skepticism, Statistical Methods, and the Cigarette: A Historical Analysis of a Methodological Debate

Abstract

The discipline of modern "risk factor" epidemiology was in its formative stages in the early 1950s, when epidemiologic studies revealed a strong association between cigarette smoking and lung cancer mortality. Many medical scientists and physicians were reluctant to accept these studies as a demonstration of causation because the methods were "statistical" and involved data collected in uncontrolled conditions outside the laboratory. But a substantial number of senior biostatisticians and epidemiologists also voiced concerns, albeit more methodologically sophisticated, about the quality of the evidence at the time. Statistical methods were just beginning to work their way into medicine and public health, and many epidemiologists and statisticians were concerned about the potential misuse of these methods by untrained investigators. When studies of smoking and lung cancer gained increasing publicity and were being used to recommend public health policies, some prominent epidemiologists and statisticians highlighted this debate in their efforts to pursue methodological reform. Participants in the debate over smoking and lung cancer saw the need for explicit and rigorous standards for evaluating etiologic hypotheses, but they held conflicting views about what those standards should be. These diverging views reflect an underlying tension within the discipline of epidemiology between the search for "objective" methods of scientific inference and the practical needs of public health research that persists today.

Data-driven identification of potential Zika virus vectors

“…While this approach is well-tested in epidemiological applications (Parascandola, 2004), it has only recently been applied to predict ecological associations, and, as such, has limitations unique to this application. To further evaluate this prediction method, we performed a modified ‘leave-one-out’ analysis, whereby we trained a model to a dataset from which a well-studied virus had been omitted, and then predicted vectors for this virus and compared them against a list of known vectors.…”

The future of death in America

“…The strong link between cigarette smoking and increased risk of mortality has been well established since 1950 (Doll 1999; Parascandola 2004). Cigarette smoking increases the risk of cardiovascular disease, lung cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease mortality, and nearly fifty other causes of death.…”

Classification, Disease and Evidence

“…For them, the scientifi c recognition of the new statistical methodology and the virtue of its application in biology and medicine were also at stake: while promoting it, they nevertheless wanted to ensure its seriousness and to protect it from approximate medical use (Parascandola 2004 ). For them, the scientifi c recognition of the new statistical methodology and the virtue of its application in biology and medicine were also at stake: while promoting it, they nevertheless wanted to ensure its seriousness and to protect it from approximate medical use (Parascandola 2004 ).…”