Simulation study of wake encounters with straight and deformed vortices

Abstract

A simulation study was conducted in order to investigate the influence of vortex deformation on wake encounter characteristics. Wake vortices tend to be strongly deformed during the decay process, depending on the atmospheric conditions in terms of turbulence and thermal stratification. For quantification of the influence of vortex deformation, encounters of an aircraft of the 'Medium' category behind a generator aircraft of the 'Heavy' category were simulated with straight vortices and with realistically deformed vortices derived from largeeddy simulations. All relevant parameters that influence the encounter characteristics, such as encounter angles and positions, were varied within a wide range. In order to cover all kinds of vortex deformation, encounters with different vortex ages from 16-136 seconds were simulated. Hence, all relevant phases during the vortex decay from nearly straight and wavy vortices to vortex rings were considered.The parameter variation study revealed that on average the impact on the encountering aircraft is less with deformed vortices than with straight vortices of comparable strength. Especially with vortex rings, the encountering aircraft is exposed to a much smaller impact. However, the results also show a larger aircraft response during encounters with wavy vortices just prior to vortex linking. The maximum aircraft response with wavy vortices is stronger than with straight vortices of comparable strength. Also, the strongest encounters occur under greater encounter angles with deformed vortices than with straight ones.

Airplane Vortex Encounters Identification Using Multilayer Feed-Forward Neural Networks

“…In fact, these results confirmed the outcomes of investigation obtained by the authors when using other types of soft-computing approaches also focused on almost the same type of critical inputs. On the other hand, researchers worldwide [22], [23] focusing on the study of vortex encounters by simulating their dynamics in order to define vortex encounter hazards, are urgently seeking answers to redefine safety measures, such as separation schemes. The expectation is to allow air traffic to increase airport capacities by revising the existing schemes while not compromising safety.…”

How Plate Lines Influence the Hazard Perception of Pilots During Wake Encounters

“…This method was deemed feasible by Barrows [23], verified against wind tunnel tests by de Bruin [24], and further validated using real flight test data by Fischenberg [25] and Jategaonkar [26]. The method was applied in various studies in the past [27][28][29][30][31][32] and is accepted to provide vortex induced forces and moments of acceptable accuracy.…”

A review of recent wake vortex research for increasing airport capacity

“…Simulations have been used to examine the influence of vortex curvature on encounter severity ( [80], [81], [82], [83], [84]). As noted by Crow [11], wakes deform as a result of the long-wave Crow instability, which in turn is driven by the ambient turbulence and in later stages by the temperature stratification [83].…”