Simulation of pedestrian evacuation route choice using social force model in large-scale public space: Comparison of five evacuation strategies

Abstract

The primary objective of this study is to compare pedestrian evacuation strategies in the large-scale public space (LPS) using microscopic model. Data were collected by video recording from Tian-yi square for 36 hours in city of Ningbo, China. A pedestrian evacuation simulation model was developed based on the social force model (SFM). The simulation model parameters, such as reaction time, elasticity coefficient, sliding coefficient, et al, were calibrated using the real data extracted from the video. Five evacuation strategies, strategy 1 (S1) to strategy 5 (S5) involving distance, density and capacity factors were simulated and compared by indicators of evacuation time and channel utilization rate, as well as the evacuation efficiency. The simulation model parameters calibration results showed that a) the pedestrians walking speed is 1.0~1.5m/s; b) the pedestrians walking diameter is 0.3~0.4m; c) the frequency of pedestrian arrival and departure followed multi-normal distribution. The simulation results showed that, (a) in terms of total evacuation time, the performance of S4 and S5 which considering the capacity and density factors were best in all evacuation scenarios, the performance of S3 which only considering the density factor was the worst, relatively, and S1 and S2 which considering the distance factor were in the middle. (b) the utilization rate of channels under S5 strategy was better than other strategies, which performs best in the balance of evacuation. S3 strategy was the worst, and S1, S2 and S4 were in the middle. (c) in terms of the evacuation efficiency, when the number of evacuees is within 2, 500 peds, the S1 and S2 strategy which considering the distance factor have best evacuation efficiency than other strategies. And when the number of evacuees is above 2, 500 peds, the S4 and S5 strategy which considering the capacity factor are better than others.

Safe Walking Route Recommender Based on Fall Risk Calculation Using a Digital Human Model on a 3D Map

“…Simulation and recommendation of evacuation methods is a type of route recommendation where public spaces are considered [8]. Such types of researches help design evacuation strategies to reduce casualties and damages in the events of natural or man-made disasters.…”

CellEVAC: An adaptive guidance system for crowd evacuation through behavioral optimization

“…Above mentioned studies have mainly dealt with the development of descriptive models of evacuation behavior that simulate the real movement of crowds (Duives et al, 2013;Ronchi et al, 2016). These models allow studying the influence of different behavior strategies on evacuation performance (Zhou et al, 2019). However, behavioral strategy optimization is neglected to great degrees (Berseth et al, 2015;Noh et al, 2016;Ding et al, 2017).…”

A Comparative Study on Drivers’ Stop/Go Behavior at Signalized Intersections Based on Decision Tree Classification Model

“…A basic assumption of the GHM model is that the driver decides whether to stop or pass the intersection according to the relationship between the maximum passing distance and the minimum stopping distance at the beginning of the yellow light. Several notable variants have also been reported in the literature [22][23][24][25]. e GHM model assumes that all drivers will choose to stop, if possible.…”