Shaping urban consolidation debates: Social representations in Brisbane newspaper media

Abstract

Recent international trends towards urban consolidation, intended to reduce outward urban sprawl by concentrating growth within existing neighbourhoods, can cause contention in cities. Understanding how the mass media represents urban consolidation can lead to more informed and democratic planning practices. This paper employs Social Representations Theory to identify and understand representations of urban consolidation in newspaper media. The theory recognises that the media is a key purveyor of public discourse and can reflect, shape or suppress ideas circulating in society. This novel approach has not previously been applied to understanding social representations of urban consolidation strategies in the mass media. The rapidly growing and changing city of Brisbane, Australia, is utilised as a case study. Brisbane is situated in South East Queensland, the fastest growing region in Australia, and is governed by regional and local planning policies that strongly support increased densities in existing urban areas. Findings from a quantitative textual analysis of 449 articles published in Brisbane newspapers between 2007 and 2014 reveal key clusters and classes of co-occurring words that represent dominant social representations apparent in the newspaper corpus. The paper provides two key conclusions. The first is that social representations occurring in mass media represent an important source of information about ‘common sense’ understandings and evaluations of urban consolidation debates. The second is that urban consolidation is represented as a multifaceted issue, including interrelated themes of housing, sustainable population growth, investment strategies and the interplay between politics and planning.

Planning for Lower-Income Households in Privately Developed High-Density Neighbourhoods in Sydney, Australia

“…Much literature on private condominium development has focused on the role of international finance (Ley, 2017;Rogers & Koh, 2017), gentrification (Lehrer & Wieditz, 2009), privatisation (Kern, 2007;Rosen & Walks, 2013), exclusion (Atkinson et al, 2005), and luxury marketing (Costello, 2005;Raynor et al, 2017). This research demonstrates how condominium development is implicated in neoliberal agendas, particularly the increasing privatisation of cities.…”

Coping with Territorial Stigma and Devalued Identities: How Do Social Representations of an Environmentally Degraded Place Affect Identity and Agency?

“…In socio-environmental research, SRT has been broadly applied to understand how different publics make sense of places ranging from natural to anthropic environments. This research contributed to examining the role of place meanings in sustainability challenges, enlightening whose representations are reproduced in conflicts around competing place claims and their effects on sustainability e.g., [34,[41][42][43].…”

Inside High-Rise Housing

“…ownership of a detached house within the suburban idyll, replete with privacy and space, came to constitute the 'proper' setting for family life (Dowling and Mee 2000). The high-rise condo, by default, is devalued as unsuitable for families, dangerous, deviant even (Raynor et al 2017;Raynor 2018). These ideals likewise distinguish the desirable, proud and responsible owner subject as someone with a stake in the property-owning democracy, from the renter whose flagrant 'rejection' of this home-owning ideal provides grounds for suspicion and disdain.…”