“…In addition, Davison (1958) reported that 11 per cent of his cases were due to thyroid insufficiency, while an additional 7 per cent were suffering from immunological deficiency. More recent work has supported the notion of hypothyroidism (Freeman and Freeman, 1960;Bierman and Furukawa, 1978), though acknowledging it as responsible in only a small number of cases. The autonomic nervous system was the other control system attracting much attention (Suehs, 1952); Hilger (1949) suggested that autonomic disturbances could underlie some glue ear cases and Hoople (1950) challenged his colleagues to 'ferret out' such cases.…”
Section: (C) Constitutional Disordersmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…This became known to ENT specialists as 'candy catarrh' (Davison 1966), a view that was accepted by some (Watkins, 1955;Rapp and Fahey. 1973), but felt to be responsible in only obscure cases by others (Freeman and Freeman, 1960). The obesity theory has continued to get some support, though the only scientific study which has examined such a relationship (Tos, Poulsen and Borch, 1979) failed to provide any.…”
Section: Review Of the Medical Literature (I) Climatementioning
confidence: 99%
“…Despite such convictions, an MRC working group (MRC, 1957) reported in 1957 that deafness as a complication of acute otitis media was becoming much less common, probably as a result of the use of antibiotics. Nevertheless the antibiotic theory continued to attract support (Freeman and Freeman, 1960;Lemon, 1962;Boor, 1962;Davison, 1966) throughout the 1960s. The first sign of apprehension about the theory came in a BMJ editorial (1969) which pointed out that there was no real evidence to support it.…”
Over the past one hundred years medical views on the cause of glue ear have frequently changed. The medical literature was reviewed to see if these changes reflected advances in the level of scientific support for different causes. This revealed that only a few of the many proposed causes command any scientific support. An explanation for the changing pattern of views on the aetiology of glue ear was therefore sought by considering secular changes in medical knowledge and belief in general. This suggested that the views held on the cause of glue ear at any given time are influenced and largely determined by the prevailing knowledge and beliefs of medicine as a whole. This phenomenon is not peculiar to glue ear--though conditions about which there is considerable uncertainty are probably more susceptible to such influences.
“…In addition, Davison (1958) reported that 11 per cent of his cases were due to thyroid insufficiency, while an additional 7 per cent were suffering from immunological deficiency. More recent work has supported the notion of hypothyroidism (Freeman and Freeman, 1960;Bierman and Furukawa, 1978), though acknowledging it as responsible in only a small number of cases. The autonomic nervous system was the other control system attracting much attention (Suehs, 1952); Hilger (1949) suggested that autonomic disturbances could underlie some glue ear cases and Hoople (1950) challenged his colleagues to 'ferret out' such cases.…”
Section: (C) Constitutional Disordersmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…This became known to ENT specialists as 'candy catarrh' (Davison 1966), a view that was accepted by some (Watkins, 1955;Rapp and Fahey. 1973), but felt to be responsible in only obscure cases by others (Freeman and Freeman, 1960). The obesity theory has continued to get some support, though the only scientific study which has examined such a relationship (Tos, Poulsen and Borch, 1979) failed to provide any.…”
Section: Review Of the Medical Literature (I) Climatementioning
confidence: 99%
“…Despite such convictions, an MRC working group (MRC, 1957) reported in 1957 that deafness as a complication of acute otitis media was becoming much less common, probably as a result of the use of antibiotics. Nevertheless the antibiotic theory continued to attract support (Freeman and Freeman, 1960;Lemon, 1962;Boor, 1962;Davison, 1966) throughout the 1960s. The first sign of apprehension about the theory came in a BMJ editorial (1969) which pointed out that there was no real evidence to support it.…”
Over the past one hundred years medical views on the cause of glue ear have frequently changed. The medical literature was reviewed to see if these changes reflected advances in the level of scientific support for different causes. This revealed that only a few of the many proposed causes command any scientific support. An explanation for the changing pattern of views on the aetiology of glue ear was therefore sought by considering secular changes in medical knowledge and belief in general. This suggested that the views held on the cause of glue ear at any given time are influenced and largely determined by the prevailing knowledge and beliefs of medicine as a whole. This phenomenon is not peculiar to glue ear--though conditions about which there is considerable uncertainty are probably more susceptible to such influences.
“…Allergy is mentioned as a possible factor in the etiology of eustachian tube malfunction in articles by Freeman,20 HeisselZ8 Hoople,2° Lemon,4l P a~a r e l l a ?~ T h e~b a l d , ~~ Tremble,'" and Sade.57 Lemon4' said clinical allergy was no more suspected or diagnosed in four hundred consecutive cases than in the general population (ten to twenty percent).…”
“…It has shown a remarkable increase during the past few years (Shah, 1975). The rise in incidence may be due to greater awareness of the problem, increased use of antibiotics, insufficient use of myringotomy after treatment of acute otitis, new types of virulent or hypovirulent infections, conservatism in adenoidectomy in children, a poor immunity mechanism and hyperplastic nasopharyngeal tissue or an increase in allergy (Freeman and Freeman, 1960).…”
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.