Here, we investigate the sensitivity of nonequilibrium Casimir forces to optical properties at low frequencies via the Drude and plasma models and the associated effects on the actuation of microelectromechanical systems. The stability and chaotic motion for both autonomous conservative and nonconservative driven systems were explored assuming good, e.g., Au, and poor, e.g., doped SiC, interacting conductors having large static conductivity differences. For both material systems, we used the Drude and plasma methods to model the optical properties at low frequencies, where measurements are not feasible. In fact, for the conservative actuating system, bifurcation and phase space analysis show that the system motion is strongly influenced by the thermal nonequilibrium effects depending on the modeling of the optical properties at low frequencies, where also the presence of residual electrostatic forces can also drastically alter the actuating state of the system, depending strongly on the material conductivity. For nonconservative systems, the Melnikov function approach is used to explore the presence of chaotic motion rendering predictions of stable actuation or malfunction due to stiction on a long-term time scale rather impossible. In fact, the thermal effects produce the opposite effect for the emerging chaotic behavior for the Au-Au and SiC-SiC systems if the Drude model is used to model the low optical frequencies. However, using the plasma model, only for the poor conducting SiC-SiC system, the chance of chaotic motion is enhanced, while for the good conducting Au-Au system, the chaotic behavior will remain unaffected at relatively short separations (<2 µm).