Scaling‐up school mental health services in low resource public schools of rural Pakistan: the Theory of Change (ToC) approach

Abstract

Background Ninety percent of children with mental health problems live in low or middle-income countries (LMICs). School-based programs offer opportunities for early identification and intervention, however implementation requires cross-sector collaboration to assure sustainable delivery of quality training, ongoing supervision, and outcomes monitoring at scale. In Pakistan, 35% of school-aged children are reported to have emotional and behavioral problems. As in many other LMICs, the government agencies who must work together to mount school-based programs have limited resources and a limited history of collaboration. The “Theory of Change” (ToC) process offers a way for new partners to efficiently develop mutual goals and long-term prospects for sustainable collaboration. Objective Develop a model for scale-up of school based mental health services in public schools of Pakistan. Methods We used ToC workshops to develop an empirically supported, ‘hypothesized pathway’ for the implementation of WHO’s School Mental Health Program in the public schools of rural Pakistan. Three workshops included 90 stakeholders such as policy makers from education and health departments, mental health specialists, researchers, head teachers, teachers and other community stakeholders including non-governmental organizations. Results The ToC process linked implementers, organizations, providers and consumers of school mental health services to develop common goals and relate them (improved child socioemotional wellbeing, grades and participation in activities) to interventions (training, monitoring and supervision of teachers; collaboration with parents, teachers and primary health care facilities and schools). Key testable assumptions developed in the process included buy-in from health care providers, education officials and professionals, community-based organizations and families. For example, teachers needed skills for managing children’s problems, but their motivation might come from seeking improved school performance and working conditions. Poverty, stigma and lack of child mental health literacy among teachers, administration, and parents were identified as key hypothesized barriers. Children and their families were identified as key stakeholders to make such a program successful. Discussion ToC workshops assisted in team building and served as a stakeholders’ engagement tool. They helped to develop and support testable hypotheses about the structures, collaborations, and knowledge most important to scaling-up school based mental health services in Pakistan.

Agents of Change for Mental Health: A Survey of Young People’s Aspirations for Participation Across Five Low- and Middle-Income Countries

“…Our results contribute to this literature, suggesting that young people in LMICs would welcome such initiatives and be motivated to codesign and codeliver these programs. To enable implementation, however, it is important to understand teachers’ or other school personnel’s perception of whether they can, should, or are equipped to support such efforts, and address potential barriers such as lack of dedicated staff or inadequate infrastructure [ 38 ].…”

Parenting Styles and Mental Health among Adolescents of Nawabshah (SBA), SINDH

“…The research adhered to a descriptive cross-sectional study design, employing non-probability convenience sampling to facilitate the selection process. This approach was informed by a report indicating a 35% prevalence of mental health issues among Pakistan's adolescent demographic (25). Utilizing the formula n=Z 2 P(1−P)/d 2, with a 95% confidence interval, a 5% margin of error, and the aforementioned prevalence rate, the sample size was determined to be approximately 354 participants.…”

Improving psychosocial distress for young adolescents in rural schools of Pakistan: study protocol of a cluster randomised controlled trial

“…The research team has culturally adapted and feasibility tested the intervention by working collaboratively with the adolescents, caregivers and school administration from the same study subdistrict. As a part of the formative phase we conducted (1) qualitative needs assessments with school adolescents to identify the priority adolescent mental health problems; (2) end-user testing workshops with adolescents in school settings to culturally adapt the EASE intervention and (3) consultative workshops with relevant stakeholders from Ministries of education and health of Pakistan, school staff including head teachers, teachers and mental health experts, parents and adolescents to develop a hypothesised pathway for the implementation of school based mental health programmes in low resource settings of Pakistan 13. Once the current trial is complete, the findings will be disseminated to participants, ministries of health and education, school education department and wider public through presentations at community and public forums.…”