Scalar fixes of environmental management in Java, Indonesia

Abstract

This paper analyses the emergence and fixing of scales in struggles over environmental issues. Using the example of watershed and coastal management in Java, we show how political framings of environmental matters and struggles over resources are linked to scalar regimes. We conceptualise these regimes as scalar fixes in which scales of intervention and scales of knowledge production are bound by environmental narratives and social–ecological processes to produce lock-in effects for prolonged periods of time. In our empirical case, particular scales were central in providing ‘problem closure’ and legitimising interventions while precluding other problematisations. Sedimentation of the Segara Anakan lagoon, first desired to support conversion into a rice bowl, was later framed as threat caused by upland peasants. The lock-in of interpretive framings and scales of observation and intervention, which was linked to politics of forest control, impeded debate on the various causes of sedimentation. With our newly defined concept of scalar fixes we contribute to understanding environmental narratives and related knowledge, providing a complement to the micro-perspectives on the stabilisation of knowledge claims currently discussed in cultural and political ecology. In doing so, we offer an approach to scalar analysis of environmental conflicts linking environmental narratives with the material social–ecological processes enrolled.

In whose interests? Water risk mitigation strategies practiced by the fruit industry in South Africa’s Western Cape

“…In the South African context, such a hegemonic narrative becomes problematic when one considers that most fruit farmers legalised their water allocations from the apartheid era through the administrative ELU-mechanism. It obfuscates the uneven power relations that influence this framing (Lukas and Flitner, 2019;Morrison et al, 2019) and leads to continued inequities in access to water resources and the benefits of water resource use.…”

Transforming the Classic Political Forest: Contentious Territories in Java

“…The widespread forest clearing changed the forest environment and produced new contradictions with regard to both production and environmental protection goals. It challenged the Department of Forestry and the SFC’s attempts to render “common sense” their narratives of centralised state control for the greater good and environmental protection; the destruction of so much forest by those denied access belied their empty discursive claims (Lukas ; Lukas and Flitner ). Moreover, no less than a president’s statement reflected the exasperation of many villagers and their supporters that the forest lands remained under centralised state control.…”

Land Cover Changes and Impacts of Massive Siltation on the Mangrove Segara Anakan Lagoon System, Cilacap Indonesia

“…In this paper the impact of improper management of upland agriculture as well as the resulting degradation of estuarine and coastal ecosystems from massive siltation were addressed (Hapsari et al, 2020;Lukas and Flitner, 2019) based on the observations in the Segara Anakan area in Central (Holtermann et al, 2009;Ardli et al, 2015).…”