Rooted in Supervision, Branching into Management: Continuity and Change in the Role of First‐Line Manager

Abstract

It is frequently argued that, as a consequence of radical organizational change, the role of first-line manager (FLM) has shifted from supervision to team leadership/co-ordination or business unit management. After reviewing the nature of these claims and the debate about the relationship between first-line management and supervision, evidence is presented from a survey of 135 organizations in London and the South East on how the role of FLM is presently defined and how it has changed. The findings paint a picture of a stable, consistent FLM role where a common performance-oriented supervisory core is surrounded by a penumbra of additional managerial responsibilities relating to stewardship, translating strategy into operations, unit management and, exceptionally, business management. The FLM role remains part of a hierarchical system of individual managerial responsibility and vertical accountability, with narrow spans of control, vertical and internal contacts and authority, participation in decisions and accountability confined largely to operating routines. Changes to the FLM role have been as much towards a strengthening of the supervisory core as a broadening into business management responsibilities. It is argued that the persistence and prevalence of the supervisory core stems from the continued location of FLMs within systems of external, hierarchical supervision. Far from being weakened, the supervisory core of the FLM role has often been strengthened by the adoption of more stringent controls over work practice in order to cope with a growth in business activity or comply with a greater range of external regulations. In some cases, however, a re-division of managerial labour has led to formerly middle management responsibilities and accountability being added to the supervisory core to produce an extended FLM role. Copyright Blackwell Publishing Ltd 2005.

‘No Place to Hide’? The Realities of Leadership in UK Supermarkets

“…In line with Hales' (2005) observations, these managers were not entrepreneurial visionaries, but links in a chain with little real influence over policies and procedures.…”

Human resource development in the hotel industry of Mauritius: myth or reality?

“…Line managers encompass departmental heads and supervisors (Hales, 2005). We specifically targeted line managers actively involved in staff training and development.…”

Clinical supervision for allied health staff: necessary but not sufficient

“…Initially, the supervisor was seen as the day-to-day contact who made sure that Receiving feedback (positive or negative) is an important component of CS 4.50 ± 0.57 CS involves reflecting on practice 4.43 ± 0.52 CS involves reflecting on relationships and interactions with patients 4.34 ± 0.50 There are many different activities that can take place during a CS session 4.30 ± 0.58 CS sessions should be guided by the supervisee's needs at the time 4.18 ± 0.65 Some preparation must be done before attending a CS session 4.17 ± 0.58 CS enables me to find solutions to problems 4.15 ± 0.52 CS involves discussion regarding the supervisee's growth, personal development goals and career pathway 4.09 ± 0.79 production continued, by focusing on task allocation throughout the work processes. 25 Over time, the role of the supervisor was expanded to take on additional functions previously considered to be the responsibility of management, such as achieving the organisation's strategy and human resource management. 25 As a result, in many industries there are few differences between the roles and expectations of supervisors and managers.…”

“…25 Over time, the role of the supervisor was expanded to take on additional functions previously considered to be the responsibility of management, such as achieving the organisation's strategy and human resource management. 25 As a result, in many industries there are few differences between the roles and expectations of supervisors and managers. In allied health organisational structures, team leaders and service and department managers carry line responsibility for the management of the allied health staff.…”