Risk of Malignancy Associated with Head and Neck CT in Children: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Objective To perform a systematic review to evaluate the risk of malignancy associated with computed tomography (CT) of the head and/or neck in infants, children, and adolescents. Data Sources Pubmed, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library were assessed from the date of their inception to January 2014. Additionally, manual searches of bibliographies were performed and topic experts were contacted. Review Methods Data were obtained from studies measuring or estimating the risks of malignancy associated with radiation from head and/or neck CT in pediatric populations according to an a priori protocol. Two independent evaluators corroborated the extracted data. Results There were 16 criterion-meeting studies that included data from n = 858,815 patients. The radiation-related risk of malignancy was estimated using primary patient data for both the exposure and outcome in a minority of studies, with most analyses utilizing mathematical modeling techniques. The data regarding otolaryngology-specific studies were limited and suggested a borderline significant increase in the risk of all combined cancers after facial CT (incidence rate ratio [IRR] = 1.14; 95% CI, 1.01–1.28) and neck/spine CT (IRR = 1.13; 95% CI, 1.00–1.28). Cohort data suggest that 1 excess brain malignancy occurred after 4000 brain CTs (40 mSv per scan) and that the estimated risk in the 10 years following CT exposure was 1 brain tumor per 10,000 patients exposed to a 10 mGy scan at less than 10 years of age. Conclusion Detailed understanding of any potential malignancy risk associated with pediatric imaging of the head and neck furthers our ability to engage in rational, shared, informed decision making with families considering CT scan.

Postoperative imaging for detection of recurrent arteriovenous malformations in children

“…1,9,16 Concern regarding the safety of radiation exposure in children has caused a shift away from studies involving the use of ionizing radiation, such as angiography and CT. 7,22 Recent estimates have placed the mean radiation dose to the skin from a single diagnostic angiogram in a child under the age of 21 at 239.4 mGy, while the dose absorbed by the brain is lower. Infants experience a slightly higher dose due to skull thickness, but the total is still less than 1 Gy.…”

“…The appropriate follow-up modality and timing are therefore subjects of debate, particularly in light of concerns regarding radiation exposure and general anesthesia in children. 7,22,30 We present our experience with surveillance for AVM recurrence, associated risk factors, and clinical outcome, while considering the implications of these findings for follow-up protocols after treatment.…”

Pediatric neurointervention: collimation on radiation exposure-associated lifetime excess tumor risk

“…Data on the estimated rate of excess long-term cancer risk is still being reported and compiled 28. Current estimates are based on large population-based retrospective studies using registry data 8 17 18.…”

Diagnostic Yield of Computed Tomography Scan for Pediatric Hearing Loss: A Systematic Review

“…89 The most rigorous data from that sister study show that if every excess brain cancer after brain CT were attributable only to the imaging itself, then approximately 1 in 4000 pediatric brain CTs would be followed by a malignancy (mean estimated radiation dose 40 mSv per scan) or 1 brain tumor per 10,000 patients (10 mGy per scan, < 10 years of age at exposure). 90,91 As temporal bone CT confers a smaller radiation dose than brain CT, the associated risks of radiation are anticipated to be even lower, although direct patient data from temporal bone imaging are very limited.…”