Return to school and mask-wearing in class during the COVID-19 pandemic: Student perspectives from a school simulation study

Abstract

Objectives This study examined children’s perspectives about returning to in-person school following lockdown due to the pandemic and about mask-wearing in class, as well as the mental health of children and parents during the pandemic. Methods This cross-sectional study was part of a 2-day school simulation exercise that randomized students to different masking recommendations. Parent-report of mental health and post-simulation child-report of COVID-19-related anxiety and mask-wearing were analyzed using descriptive and multiple regression analyses. Semi-structured focus groups were conducted with older students to supplement questionnaire data. Results Of 190 students in this study, 31% were in grade 4 or lower 95% looked forward to returning to in-person school. Greater child anxiety about COVID-19 was predicted by increased parent/caregiver anxiety (β=0.67; P<0.001), and lower parental educational attainment (β=1.86; P<0.002). Older students were more likely than younger students to report that mask-wearing interfered with their abilities to interact with peers (χ2(1)=31.16; P<0.001) and understand the teacher (χ2(1)=13.97; P<0.001). Students in the group that did not require masks were more likely than students in the masking group to report worries about contracting COVID-19 at school (χ2(1)=10.07; P<0.05), and anticipated difficulty wearing a mask (χ2(1)=18.95; P<0.001). Conclusions For children anxious about COVID-19, parental anxiety and education about COVID-19 may be targets for intervention. Future research should examine the impact of prolonged implementation of public health mitigation strategies in school on academic achievement and children’s mental health.

Children's experiences of mask‐wearing: a systemic review and narrative synthesis

“…61 Coelho et al found that younger students were less likely than older students to report that mask-wearing interfered with their abilities to interact with peers and understand teachers. 31 We therefore conclude that experiences of…”

Effect of Wearing a Face Mask on Hand-to-Face Contact by Children in a Simulated School Environment

“…Five of 12 secondary outcomes could not be assessed for logistical or technical reasons (eMethods in Supplement 1), whereas experiences of students and teachers were examined in 2 substudies, and have been reported separately. 24,25 Two outcomes were not prespecified in the protocol, but analyzed posthoc: the number of hand-to-mask contacts (codes 5 to 8) and the number of other nonmucosa face contacts (code 4) per student per hour.…”

Pandemic Education—Insights into Teachers’ Perceptions of Hygiene Measures in Schools Due to COVID-19

“…Although several studies indicate various negative effects on social interactions between teachers and students associated with the wearing of face masks in the classroom [ 19 , 21 ], Spitzer (2021) [ 17 ] emphasizes that maintaining the health of all stakeholders should remain a top priority in schools. For example, Spitzer (2021) [ 17 ] suggests compensating for the loss of emotionality through facemasks by strengthening other forms of expression such as posture and gestures.…”