Resisting the binarism of victim and agent: Critical reflections on 20 years of scholarship on young women and heterosexual practices in South African contexts

Abstract

The last 20 years have seen a proliferation of research, spurred by the imperatives of the HIV epidemic and reportedly high rates of gender-based violence, on heterosexual practices in the South African context. Research has focused on how poverty, age and gender within specific cultural contexts shape sexual agency and provide a context for unequal, coercive and violent practices for young women. This paper takes stock of what we currently 'know' about heterosex and critically reflects on the political and ideological effects of such research, specifically in the light of young women's agency. A primary concern is that efforts to address gender inequality and the normative gender practices that shape inequitable heterosexual practices may have functioned to reproduce the very discourses that underpin such inequalities. The paper 'troubles' the victim-agency binarism as it has been played out in South African research on heterosex, raising concerns about how the research may reproduce gendered, classed and raced othering practices and discourses and bolstered regulatory and disciplinary responses to young women's sexualities. The paper argues for critical, feminist self-reflexivity that should extend to re-thinking methodologies entrenched in frameworks of authority and surveillance.

Voices from the Inside: Lived Experiences of Women Confined in a Detention Center

“…Such a nuanced way of thinking about power and agency sheds light on the numerous ways in which women deal with the different regimes of power that oppress them. It also acknowledges the complexities, tensions, and contradictions that characterize their lives (see Shefer 2015).…”

“… See, e.g., MacLeod (1992),Shefer (2015),Campbell and Mannell (2016), andTuran et al (2016).6 Given the conditions of induced vulnerability(Butler, Gambetti, and Sabsay 2016) to which the women we interviewed were exposed, prior to and within detention, participants' real names have been replaced by pseudonyms.S I G N SWinter 2019 y…”

The role of agency in the implementation of Isoniazid Preventive Therapy (IPT): Lessons from oMakoti in uMgungundlovu District, South Africa

“…The onus then falls to the healthcare provider to elicit information that can help determine the needs of potential Makoti , recognising that agreement does not necessarily equate to buy in. To be clear, the term ‘agency’ is not an invitation to bestow power upon a person in order to ‘correct’ behaviour, as Shefer cautioned [ 44 ]. Rather, it is an acknowledgement that the provider’s role is limited until current life complexities are ascertained.…”

Trajetórias de mulheres vivendo com HIV/aids no Brasil. Avanços e permanências da resposta à epidemia

“…Algumas reproduziram, nas suas relações amorosas e conjugais, as relações abusivas que haviam vivenciado nas suas casas, mas outras romperam com o ciclo de violência e estabeleceram novos padrões de relacionamento afetivo e familiar, independente da sua situação de pobreza, da baixa escolaridade e da infecção pelo HIV. Ou seja, há uma capacidade de agência, por parte das mulheres, que deve ser valorizada para que não sejam reduzidas a vítimas, seja de um parceiro infiel ou violento ou de uma família desestruturada 27 . O reconhecimento desta capacidade de agência é fundamental para a compreensão das suas escolhas e na construção da vida com HIV/aids.…”