Research and teaching cultures in two contrasting UK policy contexts: Academic life in Education Departments in five English and Scottish universities

Abstract

The paper explores academic staff and departmental research and teaching cultures in the Education Departments of five universities in Scotland and England, countries with increasingly diverging public policies in respect of education. The relationship between research and teaching, how the purposes of universities are defined and the status of research in Education are current UK higher education policy preoccupations. Data is drawn from interviews with 40 academics, observation of department settings, documentation and websites. The analysis draws on the work of Bourdieu, considering the changing habitus of individual academics, their departmental and academic subject context and the forms of symbolic capital now required in Scottish and English Education departments in response to new policies affecting their academic field. The paper also utilises recent literature on the research-teaching relationship. The career trajectories of respondents, their habitus and the forms of symbolic capital that they bring to academic life are examined, as are the extent to which the teaching and research cultures in each of the five departments studied mirror each other and whether these also reflect the two different policy contexts. The themes how academic cultures are shaped and research/teaching connections viewed have international as UK relevance.

Enhancing the Quality of Research in Europe: Theoretical Perspectives on and Guiding Principles for Researcher Development

“…Notwithstanding the valuable contributions to the knowledge base made by some Europeans (e.g. Abramo et al 2009;Deem and Lucas 2007;Gordon 2005;Rees et al 2007;Vekkaila et al 2012), the bulk of the literature seems to be supplied by American and Australasian authors. Tight (2008, p. 596) identifies higher education research, as 'a developing field of study', which 'could be conceived of as a partially explored territory through which a variety of tribes traverse'.…”

The balance between teaching and research in Dutch and English universities in the context of university governance reforms

“…How do academics respond to their changing institutional environments as regards their teaching and research portfolio? Answering this question will contribute to the debates on the change and stability in the teaching-research nexus in higher education and research systems (Brew 2006;Clark 1991, Colbeck 1998de Weert 2004;Deem and Lucas 2007;Jenkins et al 2003;Durning and Jenkins 2005;McNay 1999;Smith 1999;Taylor 2007). In particular, it will help to understand what the higher education and research reforms at the macro level may mean for the basic functions of university research units.…”

Developing an identity as an EdD leader

“…Currently working in an education department as a social scientist, as opposed to having being an educational practitioner, the findings of such studies (Deem and Lucas, 2007;Clegg, 2008;Collyer, 2015) have particular resonance to this paper. Feelings of being an 'outsider' in this educational space are ever present and are associated with aligning oneself with the discipline of the social sciences.…”