Remembering motivation research: toward an alternative genealogy of interpretive consumer research

Abstract

This article traces the emergence and subsequent decline of motivation research. It argues that contrary to recent opinion that interpretive consumer research emerged in the mid-1980s, an embryonic form of interpretive research can actually be found in the 1930s in the form of motivation research. It demonstrates that there are clear and distinct parallels regarding the ontology, axiology, epistemology, methodology and view of human nature between motivation research, interpretive research and, to a limited extent, critical theory. Not only is motivation research presented as an early form of interpretive consumer research, but in addition, Holbrook's and Hirschman's experiential analysis is shown to be a possible take-off point to make the case that motivation research represents an early root of Consumer Culture Theory. This genealogical exercise resituates the emergence of the CCT discourse by 80 years and interpretive research by 60 years.

Cultural Influence on Teacher Motivation–A Country Study of Maldives

“…'Self-evaluation, perceived self-efficacy and self-set goals', according to Bandura and Cervone [32], have been shown to affect level of motivation. Subsequent to the intensified or diminished motivation, a 'complex interplay between the [doers], the group and the society in which they are placed' foster or hinder actions [33]. Actions, to a large 1 No definition of motivation has gained universal acceptance.…”

Final thoughts on amnesia and marketing theory

“…Interestingly, he bypasses the history of motivation research, with all its connotations of 'hidden persuaders' and so on, that might be construed as placing his account on the kind of subjective ground that he prefers to distance himself from (Bargh, 2002;Dholakia, 1988). This is in spite of the genealogical linkages between his work and that of Ernest Dichter 1 (see Tadajewski, 2006b). …”

Redefining B2B relationship marketing: Insight from postmodern Alibaba

“…Had it been, its ontology of fragmentation, multiple, holistic, socially constructed perspectives of reality (Tadajewski, 2006) would have been in doubt, and may have constituted a form of metanarrative thus contradicting one of the postmodern literature's most influential figures in JeanFrancois Lyotard. As such it is necessary to see the postmodern contribution as a series of fragmented, inspirations that provoked critical redefinition of established practice and theory in marketing.…”

“…Secondly, they point to the ultimate value of consumption as residing with the shared experience of the consumer, not in the individual sense but ultimately as part of an emancipated community of shared emotional and symbolic values. These two contributions evidence what Tadajewski (2006) refers to as a rise in interpretivist marketing contributions whose ontology center around socially constructed, holistic, multiple, fragmented and contextual perspectives of reality. Further, at the epistemological level they support Tadajewski's (2006, p.430) assertion that 'knowledge is not approached from the standpoint of an external, objective position, but from the lived experience of the research coparticipant'.…”