Religion and ethnicity: Judaism in the ethnic consciousness of contemporary Russian Jews

Abstract

Jews have debated whether they are a racial, religious, ethnic or cultural group. Historically, Judaism (religion) and Jewish ethnicity have been fused. The Soviet regime suppressed traditional Jewish identities and substituted a secular, socialist Jewishness based on Yiddish which proved unpopular. Now that they are free to reconstruct Jewish life, we interviewed 1,300 Jews in three Russian cities to ascertain what they think being Jewish means. Judaism plays a very small role in their conceptions of Jewishness. To the extent that religious rituals are observed, they are manifestations of 'symbolic ethnicity'. Many do not 'feel' Jewish because their culture and consciousness are largely Russian. Nevertheless, they are interested in learning more about Jewish traditions and culture. A Jewish 'civil religion' may emerge in Russia. Jewish identities have varied over space and time, and a uniquely Russian Jewish identity may evolve in the coming years.

Religion and Ethnicity Among New Immigrants: The Impact of Majority/Minority Status in Home and Host Countries

“…Hammond and Warner also suggest that the relationship of religion and ethnicity is strongest in "ethnic fusion" and least strong in "religious ethnicity." Recently, some scholars have argued that even Jews' religion and culture (ethnicity) can be distinguished from each other and are separable (Chervyakov, Gitelman, and Shapiro 1997;Gans 1994). Hammond and Warner's (1993) typology, while a significant scholarly contribution, is nonetheless incomplete.…”

‘National mission’: biopolitics, non-Jewish immigration and Jewish conversion policy in contemporary Israel

“…Well aware of the cultural orientations of Soviet Jewry, namely of its emphasis on descent, kinship and ethnic Jewishness, as well as its clear secular tendencies (see, among others, Chervyakob, Gitelman and Shapiro 1997), the conversion campaign targeted at FSU immigrants is deliberately framed in national, rather than religious, terms. This intentional strategy is articulated in the words of Moshe Adorian, a senior administrator in the Education Ministry:…”

Resisting assimilation – ethnic boundary maintenance among Jews in Sweden

“…More recent survey studies performed with members of Stockholm's Jewish congregation suggest that Jews in Sweden in general view their Jewishness as mainly a matter of ethnicity and not religion (Fischer 1996;Dencik 2007), a conception of Jewishness that they share with Jews in other parts of Europe and North America (e.g. Chervyakov, Gitelman, and Shapiro 1997;Meyer 1990;Webber 1997). It will also be noted that since Jews have arrived in Sweden from different countries and through very different contexts of migration, Swedish Jews should not be seen as one unambiguously delineated ethnic grouprather, Jews in Sweden make up a diverse group who only have in common their connection, in some way, to the global Jewish community (cf.…”