Early retention or initial threshold voltage shift (IVS) is one of the key reliability challenges in charge trapping memory (CTM) based 3D NAND flash. Re-program scheme was introduced in quad-level-cell (QLC) NAND flash [1]-[4], and the IVS improvement by re-program scheme was reported. In this work, it is found that re-program can suppress ~81% of IVS in 3D NAND, which is much more significant than that of 2D NAND ~50% [5]. The mechanisms of IVS improvement by re-program scheme in 3D NAND are investigated.