“…In this regard, the number of studies in this area has increased especially in recent years. Some of the research consists of panel data analysis including certain country groups (Acaravcı & Erdoğan, 2018;Ali et al, 2023;Altinoz et al, 2020;Aye & Edoja, 2017;Chen & Huang, 2013;Coondoo & Dinda, 2002;Dimitriadis et al, 2021;Fernández-Amador et al, 2017;Hdom, 2019;Ito, 2016;Koengkan et al, 2020;Lee & Brahmasrene, 2014;Lu, 2017;Magazzino, 2014Magazzino, , 2017Mahmoodi, 2017;Maku & Ikpuri, 2020;Muhammad, 2019;Radmehr et al, 2021;Rasoulinezhad & Saboori, 2018;Saidi & Hammami, 2015;Wang et al, 2011) whereas others are time-series analysis studies that examine countries individually (Ahmad et al, 2016;Çetin & Sezen, 2018;Dertli & Yinaç, 2018;Durğun & Durğun, 2018;Emir & Bekun, 2019;Karagöl et al, 2007;Khoshnevis Yazdi & Shakouri, 2018;Li et al, 2017;Li-wei, 2012;Long et al, 2015;Özbay & Pehlivan, 2021;Salari et al, 2021;Shahbaz & Leitão, 2013;Terzi & Pata, 2016;Turan & Aksoy, 2021;Uyğun & Günay, 2018;...…”