Registered dietitians' perceptions and use of the plant‐based recommendations in the 2019 Canada's Food Guide

Abstract

Background In 2019, Canada's Food Guide underwent its first transformation in over a decade. The change received considerable attention given the increased focus on plant‐based proteins and the decision to eliminate the milk and alternatives food group. Yet little is known about health professionals' views of these updates. In response, the present study examined Canadian dietitians' attitudes and behaviours towards the guide's expanded plant‐based recommendations. Methods A pan‐Canadian cross‐sectional online survey was administered from January to March 2020 to currently practicing registered dietitians. The study was pre‐registered, piloted and received ethical approval. Descriptive and inferential statistics were performed and open‐text responses underwent thematic analysis. Results In total, 411 dietitians from 10 provinces and various work settings participated. Most dietitians (82.8%) consider the food guide's recommendation to choose protein foods that come from plants more often is evidence‐based. Compared to its predecessor, dietitians encourage their patients/clients to choose protein foods that come from plants (p < 0.001) and non‐dairy sources of calcium (p < 0.001) significantly more frequently under the new guide. A slight majority of dietitians (57.7%) agree with the decision to omit the standalone milk and alternatives group in favour of bringing dairy into the protein category. Conclusions Canadian dietitians generally look favourably upon the new plant‐based recommendations and have adjusted their nutrition counselling in response. The findings are considered to be the first to characterise how dietitians view changes to the plant‐based content of one of the most recognisable diet‐related educational tools in Canada.

Knowledge of health professionals about vegetarian diets: integrative review

“…Most included studies were quantitative [14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22] . The only one with a qualitative-quantitative approach was McHugh et al 23 .…”

“…Three articles [20][21][22] included nutritionists or dietitians in the sample, and they have three different designs. Asher et al 20 analyzed dietitians' perspectives regarding the new Canadian guideline, which includes more open recommendations on plant-based protein alternatives. Here, the professionals seemed to have appreciated the change and implemented the new recommendations.…”

Acceptability of Plant-Based Diets for People with Chronic Kidney Disease: Perspectives of Renal Dietitians

“…Interest in plant-based diets as a therapeutic option for CKD continues to grow globally, and recent studies have explored dietitians [ 41 , 42 ] and nephrology professionals’ [ 43 ] perceptions of plant-based eating. However, to our knowledge, this is the first study to provide explicit information on what might be required in practice to implement plant-based diets and strategies dietitians could use to support their patients with CKD to consume more plant foods.…”

Relationship between adherence to the 2019 Canada’s Food Guide recommendations on healthy food choices and nutrient intakes in older adults

“…The release of the CFG-2019 elicited positive reactions (8, 9), but also raised concerns on nutrient adequacy. For example, preliminary modeling of eating patterns consistent with the CFG-2019 plate snapshot revealed that adherence may be insufficient to meet calcium and vitamin D requirements (10).…”