Reflections on the Economic‐Noneconomic Debate: A Radical Geographical Perspective from the European South

Abstract

This paper expands upon the economic/noneconomic (cultural turn) debate in economic geography and proposes an alternative radical perspective through the lens of the European South. Based on the experience of Greece, the paper argues that no matter how important the cultural issues might be, the great political economy problems of distorted growth and incomplete development, sociospatial inequalities, and weak, incoherent and contradictory territorial policies continue to have a primary importance. The paper reviews some basic points of the cultural turn debate and then examines the orientations of radical spatioeconomic thought in postdictatorial (post-1974) Greece in arguing that this thought was mostly problem-driven, policy-oriented and focused upon the political economy of Greek socioeconomic and territorial restructuring. It is argued that a southern radical agenda has to be based more deliberately on holistic and inclusive interdisciplinary resyntheses in which cultural issues are given due attention, but not to the detriment of a radical understanding of the territorial workings of economy, society and power relations. The concluding suggestion of the paper is that it is a political turn, rather than a cultural turn, that is best suited to a radical interpretation of South European economic geographies.

Going toward Resilience? Town Planning, Peri-Urban Landscapes, and the Expansion of Athens, Greece

“…The historical development of Athens, considered within the wider urban network of the country, has been influenced by the predominant role of the capital city since the 1950s at the expense of all other Greek cities [37]. Attica, and its main city Athens, was the main engine of territorial development for at least one century in Greece [38]; the spatial imbalance between Athens and the rest of the country (possibly excluding only Thessaloniki, the second city in the country) has continued uninterrupted until the beginning of the 1980s [39,40]. In the modern globalized economy, Athens is the only metropolitan centre in Greece with a well-recognized international role [41].…”

‘Southern’ Alternatives of Urban Diffusion: Investigating Settlement Characteristics and Socio‐Economic Patterns in Three Mediterranean Regions

“…The singularity of this region puts into question the valid use of linear approaches; in fact, as stated by Kourliouros (, p. 792) in his discussion about the ‘cultural turn’ in economic geography from a Southern European perspective, this region needs to be investigated based on ‘a deliberately holistic political‐economic framework including and resynthesising various aspects and processes of change’. On the same line, Minca () calls for an integration of ‘quantitative’ and ‘qualitative’ approaches (e.g.…”

Blurring boundaries: informal practices in formal employment in Ireland

“…Furthermore, the formal economy can also be portrayed as ‘good’, while informal practices are often perceived as ‘bad’ (Gibson‐Graham, ; Kourliouros, ). This division follows the framework of the dual labour market economy (Tokman, ).…”