Reflecting on Behavioral Spillover in Context: How Do Behavioral Motivations and Awareness Catalyze Other Environmentally Responsible Actions in Brazil, China, and Denmark?

Abstract

Responding to serious environmental problems, requires urgent and fundamental shifts in our day-to-day lifestyles. This paper employs a qualitative, cross-cultural approach to explore people’s subjective self-reflections on their experiences of pro-environmental behavioral spillover in three countries; Brazil, China, and Denmark. Behavioral spillover is an appealing yet elusive phenomenon, but offers a potential way of encouraging wider, voluntary lifestyle shifts beyond the scope of single behavior change interventions. Behavioral spillover theory proposes that engaging in one pro-environmental action can catalyze the performance of others. To date, evidence for the phenomenon has been mixed, and the causal processes governing relationships between behaviors appear complex, inconsistent and only partly understood. This paper addresses a gap in the literature by investigating accounts of behavioral spillover in three diverse cultural settings using qualitative semi-structured interviews. The analysis shows that while around half of participants overall who were questioned recalled spillover effects, the other half had not consciously experienced spillover. There were few significant differences across cultures, though some forms of spillover effects were reported more in some cultures than others. More environmentally engaged participants across all three countries were significantly more likely to experience spillover than those who were less engaged. Accounts of within-domain spillovers were most commonly reported, mainly comprising waste, resource conservation and consumption-related actions. Accounts of between-domain spillover were very rare. Recollection of contextual and interpersonal spillover effects also emerged from the interviews. Our findings suggest that more conscious behavioral spillover pathways may be limited to those with pre-existing environmental values. Behavioral spillover may comprise multiple pathways incorporating conscious and unconscious processes. We conclude that targeting behavioral catalysts that generate more socially diffuse spillover effects could offer more potential than conventional spillover involving a single individual.

Nudge plus: incorporating reflection into behavioral public policy

“…However, since the experience of reflection through the plus can be unconscious, the resulting behavioral spillover can also happen unconsciously. For instance, Nash et al (2019) use qualitative semistructured interviews to show that around half their sample respondents, on self-reflection, unconsciously engaged in behavioral spillovers. This setup creates the following testable implications: H1: Nudge plus empowers agents and increases their autonomy compared with classic nudges only.…”

A Research Agenda to Better Understand the Human Dimensions of Energy Transitions

“…Will engagement in actions that reduce fossil energy use provide a licence to refrain from other energy-saving actions (i.e., "negative spillover"), and if so, under which conditions is this most likely to be the case? More importantly, which factors promote "positive spillover, " in which case actors would consistently engage in sustainable energy behaviour, over and again, in many different situations, which is needed to achieve a truly sustainable energy transition (Nash et al, 2019)?…”

Exploring the Effect of Collective Cultural Attributes on Covid-19-Related Public Health Outcomes

“…Such objectives can be imperative in public health crises. While social norms can guide citizens to act in a socially appropriate way (Morris et al, 2015 ), cultural distinctions can nevertheless impact the manner in which encouraged socially conscious behaviors are adopted by individuals (Nash et al, 2019 ). However, the extent to which such differences in sociocultural norms may influence important outcomes during such a health crisis has not yet been thoroughly explored.…”