Aggregates formed
between organo-phosphoric acids and imine bases
in aprotic solvents are the reactive intermediates in Brønsted
acid organo-catalysis. Due to the strong hydrogen-bonding interaction
of the acids in solution, multiple homo- and heteroaggregates are
formed with profound effects on catalytic activity. Yet, due to the
similar binding motifs—hydrogen-bonds—it is challenging
to experimentally quantify the abundance of these aggregates in solution.
Here we demonstrate that a combination of nuclear magnetic resonance
(NMR) and dielectric relaxation spectroscopy (DRS) allows for accurate
speciation of these aggregates in solution. We show that only by using
the observables of both experiments heteroaggregates can be discriminated
with simultaneously taking homoaggregation into account. Comparison
of the association of diphenyl phosphoric acid and quinaldine or phenylquinaline
in chloroform, dichloromethane, or tetrahydrofuran suggests that the
basicity of the base largely determines the association of one acid
and one base molecule to form an ion-pair. We find the ion-pair formation
constants to be highest in chloroform, slightly lower in dichloromethane
and lowest in tetrahydrofuran, which indicates that the hydrogen-bonding
ability of the solvent also alters ion-pairing equilibria. We find
evidence for the formation of multimers, consisting of one imine base
and multiple diphenyl phosphoric acid molecules for both bases in
all three solvents. This subsequent association of an acid to an ion-pair
is however little affected by the nature of the base or the solvent.
As such our findings provide routes to enhance the overall fraction
of these multimers in solution, which have been reported to open new
catalytic pathways.