Quality, Subjectivity, and Sustained Superior Performance at the Olympic Games

Abstract

I n some competitions, performance evaluation includes a substantial subjective component. We argue that the inherent uncertainty and ambiguity in subjective evaluation can lead to favorable ex post treatment for reputationally privileged competitors. Post consumption, judges may infer quality that is not directly observed and/or make conservative choices to assuage accountability concerns. We examine these issues in the context of the Olympic Games, comparing country-level performance outcomes across Olympic sports. We find that past performance is predictive of current performance in all sports, but the effect is stronger in subjective outcome sports versus objective outcome sports. That is, past performance is a better predictor of future performance in sports where external judges and referees can influence the outcomes. We find the same pattern in individual boxing matches, with past country-level performance having a stronger effect on subjective boxing outcomes (judges' decisions) than objective boxing outcomes (knockouts).Data, as supplemental material, are available at http://dx.

Private action in public interest: The comparative governance of social issues

“…Third, ex post information asymmetry may arise where transactions are complex and their outcomes are causally ambiguous (Chi, 1994;Lippman & Rumelt, 1982), so that it may be hard to tell, even ex post, whether the observed outcome was the result of deliberate action (or inaction) on the part of the transaction partner. Finally, ex post information asymmetry may also result from challenges in measuring transaction outcomes (Besley & Ghatak, 2005;Chi, 1994;Hwang & Powell, 2009), for instance, where the outcomes of a transaction are imperfectly measured so that there is a gap between perfunctory performance and consummate performance, leaving room for quality-shading (Hart, 2003(Hart, , 2008Hart & Moore, 2008) and moral hazard (Chi, 1994;Hölmstrom, 1979;Luo, Kaul, & Seo, 2018); where the benefits to the recipient are complex (Hölmstrom & Milgrom, 1991) or subjective (Waguespack & Salomon, 2015); or where measurement is costly, making comprehensive assessment infeasible . In all these cases, ex post information asymmetry impairs the functioning of markets, making it challenging for transacting parties to correctly assess the value of transactions (Anheier & Ben-Ner, 1997;Hansmann, 1980), and causing skeptical actors to choose not to transact, while naïve actors receive less than they pay for.…”

When Does Medici Hurt Da Vinci? Mitigating the Signaling Effect of Extraneous Stakeholder Relationships in the Field of Cultural Production

“…Such endeavor, however, would require a setting in which objective and subjective judgements can be clearly distinguished, and there is a variance in the balance between those two components. In the context of Olympic games, Waguespack & Salomon (2015) have found that evaluators tend to rely more on past appraisal when judgment has a stronger subjective component.…”

Seeding and gold medal probability in wrestling: a 2016 Rio Olympic Games analysis

“…tennis, football, and judo) the seeded application is implemented (Arabzad, Ghorbani & Shirouyehzad, 2014;Hizan, Whipp & Reid, 2011;Julio et al, 2015). In any sport, seeding favours the reputable competitors by affording them a theoretically easier route to the championship (Waguespack & Salomon, 2015). However, in combat sports, the ranking position seems to be a poor predictor of the final result during the Olympic Games and World Championships in judo (Vellosa Breviglieri et al, 2018), and some weight categories (Krumer, 2017) are more balanced than others.…”