Psychomotor testing and the ability to perform an anastomosis in junior surgical trainees

Abstract

Ten junior surgical trainees underwent objective testing of manual dexterity and visuospatial ability and were required to carry out five consecutive anastomoses on fresh porcine jejunum. Anastomoses were scored by a single observer and a cumulative error score (CES) derived for each procedure. In the first anastomosis there was little correlation between the psychomotor test results and the anastomosis scores. In subsequent trials there were significant negative correlations between aspects of manual dexterity and the CES. Over the five anastomoses there were significant negative correlations between improvement and manual dexterity, but there was a positive correlation between improvement and visuospatial ability (rs = 0.76, P < 0.005). Visuospatial skills are more important than pure motor ability in predicting the capacity to perform an anastomosis and tests of manual dexterity may be misleading in this context.

Virtual Reality Applied to Procedural Testing: The Next Era

“…8 -11 Other criteria such as stress tolerance and tests of visuospatial abilities have demonstrated better correlation. [12][13][14] Directly testing procedural skills through computer simulations may offer a more reliable measure of one's ability to perform specific tasks. 15 For simulators to gain acceptance into training programs, they need to be evaluated for their efficacy in teaching and evaluating procedural skills.…”

Visuospatial ability factors and performance variables in laparoscopic simulator training

“…Correlations with surgical performance for this factor differ. Tests for this factor show positive correlations with surgical performance in some research (Gibbons, Baker, & Skinner, 1986;Steele, Walder, & Herbert, 1992) but not in others (Luursema et al, 2010;Schueneman et al, 1984). 5.…”

Learning a spatial skill for surgery: how the contributions of abilities change with practice

“…Similarly, several studies have demonstrated a correlation between surgical skills and performance on the embedded figures test (Witkin, Oltman, & Karp, 1971), which measures the ability to distinguish 2D shapes within complex visual backgrounds (Gibbons, Baker, & Skinner, 1986;Gibbons, Gudas, & Gibbons, 1983;Steele, Walder, & Herbert, 1992). Using a comprehensive battery of psychometric tests, Schueneman and colleagues identified a cluster of cognitive functions underlying a factor that they labelled complex visuo-spatial organization.…”