Psychology, Philosophy, and Cognitive Science: Reflections on the History and Philosophy of Experimental Psychology

Abstract

This article critically examines the views that psychology first came into existence as a discipline ca. 1879, that philosophy and psychology were estranged in the ensuing decades, that psychology finally became scientific through the influence of logical empiricism, and that it should now disappear in favor of cognitive science and neuroscience. It argues that psychology had a natural philosophical phase (from antiquity) that waxed in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, that this psychology transformed into experimental psychology ca. 1900, that philosophers and psychologists collaboratively discussed the subject matter and methods of psychology in the first two decades of the twentieth century, that the neobehaviorists were not substantively influenced by the Vienna Circle, that the study of perception and cognition in psychology did not disappear in the behaviorist period and so did not reemerge as a result of artificial intelligence, linguistics, and the computer analogy, that although some psychologists adopted the language-of-thought approach of traditional cognitive science, many did not, and that psychology will not go away because it contributes independently of cognitive science and neuroscience.

History of psychology in Ghana since 989AD

“…Indeed, Western psychology became distinct from its origin, natural philosophy or theology, through its resolution of its metaphysical questions (Hatfield, 2002). Watson (1967, p. 435) noted that:…”

What is the status of theoretical psychology in Australia and New Zealand? An investigation of contemporary teaching and research issues

“…Psychology's interest in conceptual issues has been important despite its break with philosophy to establish a separate scientific and professional identity (Hatfield, 2002). Early figures such as William James combined philosophy with psychology while, more recently, Skinner articulated an atheoretical but equally sweeping behaviourist alternative to the perceived excesses of ''grand theory'' psychoanalysis.…”

A psicologia cognitiva experimental cinqüenta anos depois: a crise do paradigma do processamento de informação

“…O conhecimento sobre o cérebro no plano celular e intercelular, aliado a um conjunto de técni-cas de imageamento cerebral (Imbert, 1998;Kandel, Schwartz, & Jessell, 1997), têm permitido se pensar na eliminação da psicologia "folk" em detrimento de um processo de naturalização da mente, reduzindo a psicologia às neurociências (Searle, 1997;Teixeira, 2000). Para Hatfield (2002) A few recent thinkers believe that psychology can remain scientific only by becoming something else: neuroscience, cognitive science, or those and more (p. 207).…”