Psychological reactions after multifetal pregnancy reduction: a 2-year follow-up study

Abstract

This study had two objectives. Firstly we assessed the effects of multifetal pregnancy reduction on the mothers' emotional well-being and the relationship with the children during the 2 years following intervention. Secondly at 2 years we compared mothers who had a reduction with mothers who had not and had delivered triplets. The comparisons focused on the mothers' health and their relationship with the children. Women having had a reduction in two hospitals in Paris, between May 1992 and June 1993, were contacted just after intervention for a prospective study. In all, 18 women were included. At 1 and 2 years, 10 women participated. At 2 years, 10 additional women were included. The answers of these 20 mothers were compared to those of 11 consecutive mothers of 2 year old triplets, assessed by the same psychologist in a previous prospective study. Semi-structured interviews were conducted at home. The mothers' social characteristics, their parity, the children's condition at birth and 4 months were very similar between the reduction and triplet groups. One year after birth one-third of the women in the reduction group reported persistent depressive symptoms related to the reduction, mainly sadness and guilt. The others made medical and rational comments expressing no emotion. At 2 years all but two women seemed to have overcome the emotional pain associated with the reduction. The comparison with mothers of triplets indicated that the mothers' anxiety and depression, and difficult relationship with the children were less acute in the reduction group. These results presented some limitations, since a high number of women who miscarried or refused to participate in the follow-up were not assessed at 1 and 2 years. However, a majority of women who participated in the study 2 years after intervention seemed able to accept a multifetal pregnancy reduction to achieve parental goals.

The effect of legislation on outcomes of assisted reproduction technology: lessons from the 2004 Italian law

“…In addition, such a preventive policy is certainly better than the potential available ''cure'' in the form of multifetal pregnancy reduction, with its related risks of total pregnancy loss and residual maternal psychological morbidity (6). However, whether such policies are suitable for all patients, in particular for those of advanced age and/or those with repeated failures, is a matter of continued controversy, and is the basis of most current modus vivendi guidelines issued by infertility experts and organizations worldwide.…”

Multifetal Pregnancy Reduction and Selective Termination: The Canadian Experience

“…By offering the procedure 'close to home' it is hoped that costs to the health care system may be reduced and, more importantly, that the sense of isolation and, therefore, the significant psychological morbidity following these procedures [4,5] will be minimized.…”

“…It has been justified ethically that reducing the total number of fetuses in both a high-order multiple pregnancy and a multiple pregnancy discordant for fetal anomaly results in a continuing pregnancy, with the provision of the least harm and the maximum benefits for both mothers and fetuses [1,2]. However, these procedures certainly provide no panacea [3][4][5].…”

Comparative study of the psychosocial risks associated with families with multiple births resulting from assisted reproductive technology (ART) and without ART

“…The CES-D has been widely used in studies on depression in families with MB (16,(34)(35)(36)(37)(38)(39).…”