Proximity Does Not Equal Access: Racial Disparities in Access to High Quality Dialysis Facilities

Abstract

Background For patients receiving hemodialysis, distance to their dialysis facility may be particularly important due to the need for thrice weekly dialysis. We sought to determine whether African-Americans and Whites differ in proximity and access to high quality dialysis facilities. Methods We analyzed urban, Whites and African-Americans aged 18-65 receiving in-center hemodialysis linked to data on neighborhood and dialysis facility quality measures. In multivariable analyses, we examined the association between individual and neighborhood characteristics, and our outcomes: distance from home zip code to nearest dialysis facility, their current facility and the nearest high quality facility, as well as likelihood of receiving dialysis in a high quality facility. Results African-Americans lived a half mile closer to a dialysis facility (B=-0.52) but traveled the same distance to their own dialysis facility compared to Whites. In initial analysis, African-Americans are 14% less likely than their White counterparts to attend a high quality dialysis facility (OR 0.86); and those disparities persist, though are reduced, even after adjusting for region, neighborhood poverty and percent African-American. In predominately African-American neighborhoods, individuals lived closer to high quality facilities (B=--5.92), but were 53% less likely to receive dialysis there (OR 0.47, highest group versus lowest, p<0.05). Living in a predominately African-American neighborhood explains 24% of racial disparity in attending a high quality facility. Conclusions African-Americans' proximity to high quality facilities does not lead to receiving care there. Institutional and social barriers may also play an important role in where people receive dialysis.

Racial Disparities in Invasive Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus Infections, 2005–2014

“…For example, utilization of cardiac and surgical outcomes, as well as inpatient discharge data, have shown quality-of-care disparities for minority populations increasingly associated with differences in the hospitals serving these populations, rather than differences in care provided within a hospital to different population groups [22–25]. Black hemodialysis patients are less likely than whites to utilize dialysis facilities rated as high quality by federal quality reporting programs, even though they live a significantly shorter distance from these facilities [26]. …”

Travel burden and dentist bypass among dentally insured children

“…Previous research has found higher rates of provider bypass and greater travel burdens among health disparity populations . These are hypothesized to be related to racial and economic segregation and provider‐sided barriers.…”

Availability of Healthcare Resources and Colorectal Cancer Outcomes Among Non-Hispanic White and Non-Hispanic Black Adults

“…Third, healthcare strategies that include ongoing training to improve cultural competencies among healthcare personnel in Black communities may go a long way toward ensuring that interactions are positive and culturally sensitive, thereby encouraging patients to access the existing resources. A recent study observed that for African Americans, living in close proximity to a high quality facility did not necessarily increase their likelihood of receiving care there [22], highlighting a possible influence of institutional and social barriers to healthcare. We observed that although NH-W CRC patients resided in counties that had fewer oncology hospitals and medical doctors compared with NH-B patients, increasing the availability of these resources improved outcomes significantly.…”