Promoting the strengths and resilience of an Indigenous community through photovoice

Abstract

In the face of negative media attention, community members and Elders from the First Nation community of Maskwacis identified the importance of promoting community strengths and reframing perceptions of their community. Two research questions were addressed: (1) How do youth in Maskwacis view their community strengths? and (2) To what extent can photographs be used as a tool for reframing perceptions of an Indigenous community? A community-based participatory research approach was used for the current photovoice project, through which two Elders and eleven youth were engaged. Indigenous photographers trained youth participants, and Elders mentored youth to capture photographs that represented their community's strengths and resilience. Youth selected forty photos to display at a total of six photo exhibits, where feedback was gathered from 392 attendees using brief questionnaires. The content of their photos was analyzed using thematic analysis. This resulted in four themes that described the strengths of Maskwacis, reflecting the community's strong relationships, commitment to culture, the beautiful natural world that is a part of Maskwacis, and the community's ability to look toward the future. In addition, findings provide foundational support for the use of photographs to reframe perceptions of an Indigenous community. The majority (93%) of survey respondents provided examples of ways that viewing the photos had positively changed their perceptions of Maskwacis. This study prompts consideration of the strengths and resilience of other Indigenous communities facing similar social and health issues. Therefore, findings are highly relevant to paediatric health care providers seeking to provide culturally responsive care.

Indigenous Women Voicing Experiences of HIV Stigma and Criminalization Through Art

“…The analysis integrated both an iterative CBPR approach and an Indigenous analysis approach (Bird-Naytowhow et al, 2017;Castleden et al, 2008;Kovach, 2009;Tremblay et al, 2018). The broad analysis steps were as follows: (a) photo selection, in which participants identified photos that were most representative of experiences in relation to the research question; (b) contextualizing, in which participants provided a narrative describing the meaning of their selected photos; and (c) codifying, through an iterative process of participatory thematic analysis (Tremblay et al, 2018). Peer Researchers led the analysis, which drew on a structural determinants framework that centred on the influences of colonial violence and resilience.…”

Growing PEACHnet: Building a Practice-Based Research Network in Western Colorado

“…Identifying strengths when working in community engagement allows communities to understand and use solutions that are appropriate and practical in their own communities, which will be crucial to our success as a PBRN in western Colorado. 16…”

“…As we were committed to a topic-generating process that allowed people to express their own perspectives and opinions on the direction our research should take, we selected 2 participatory methods, Photovoice, 15,16 and Nominal Group Technique 1,7 to use in the second round of meetings. Although there are many useful participatory group discussion methods available, we believe these 2 methods would encourage all meeting attendees to share their perspectives and opinions.…”

Violence at the Intersections of Women’s Lives in an Urban Context: Indigenous Women’s Experiences of Leaving and/or Staying With an Abusive Partner

“…These findings closely align with the results from our previous and ongoing program of research (Varcoe et al, 2017, 2019), and indicate that safe and effective services and supports for Indigenous women with histories of IPV incorporate opportunities for women to connect with one another, their cultures, and their cultural identities as Indigenous women (Browne et al, 2016). As others have argued, photovoice may offer a particularly promising intervention for fostering the strength and resilience of Indigenous women and families (Tremblay et al, 2018).…”