Projecting Thailand physician supplies between 2012 and 2030: application of cohort approaches

Abstract

BackgroundThis study forecasts physician supply between 2012 and 2030 using cohort analysis, based on future production capacity and losses from the profession, and assesses if, and by when, the projected numbers of physicians would meet the targets of one doctor per 1,500 population, as proposed by the 7th National Conference on Medical Education in 2001, and one per 1,800, proposed by the Ministry of Public Health (MoPH) in 2004.MethodsWe estimated the annual loss rate that best reflected the dynamics of existing practising doctors, then applied this rate to the existing physicians, plus the newly licensed physicians flowing into the pool over the next two decades (from 2012 to 2030). Finally, the remaining practising physicians, after adjustment for losses, were verified against demand projections in order to identify supply gaps.ResultsThailand has been experiencing an expansion in the total number of physicians, with an annual loss rate of 1%. Considering future plans for admission of medical students, the number of licensed physicians flowing into the pool should reach 2,592 per annum, and 2,661 per annum, by 2019 and 2030 respectively. By applying the 1% loss rate to the existing, and future newly licensed, physicians, there are forecast to be around 40,000 physicians in active clinical service by 2016, and in excess of 60,000 by 2028.ConclusionThis supply forecast, given various assumptions, would meet the targets outlined above, of one doctor per 1,800 population, and one per 1,500 population, by 2016 and 2020 respectively. However, rapid changes in the contextual environment, e.g. economic demand, physician demographics, and disease burden, may mean that the annual loss rate of 1% used in this projection is not accurate in the future. To ensure population health needs are met, parallel policies on physician production encompassing both qualitative and quantitative aspects should be in place. Improved, up-to-date information and establishment of a physician cohort study are recommended.

Attitudes toward working in rural areas of Thai medical, dental and pharmacy new graduates in 2012: a cross-sectional survey

“…This corresponds to the guidelines recommended by WHO in 2010 and also various international reports and studies [10-15]. The most clearly targeted programmes are the ‘Collaborative Project to Increase Production of Rural Doctors (CPIRD)’, launched in 1995, and ‘One District One Doctor (ODOD)’ which was launched in 2005 [6,8,16,17]. These provide a special admission mode (special track) in parallel to the existing methods of national entrance examination and direct admission.…”

“…This contract system was then expanded to other professions such as nurses and dentists; however, working in public facilities remained voluntary for pharmacists. More recently, the past two decades have seen the founding of a number of new health professional schools, mostly outside Bangkok and the vicinity [5,6]. Civil servant posts and financial incentives have been provided, on top of the regular salary, to offset the opportunity loss of working in remote areas [5,8].…”

Medical tourism in Thailand: a cross-sectional study

“…Although Thailand has 18 public medical schools and one private one – that together produce about 2500 new graduates annually, 34 there remains a shortfall in doctors. It has been estimated that at the current rate of training, Thailand will not achieve its targeted physician density – of one per 1500 people – until 2020 34 . The situation is compounded by the distribution of doctors, with an acute shortage in rural areas.…”

Health workforce contributions to health system development: a platform for universal health coverage

“…Their production capacity increased from less than 35% of the country's medical graduates in 2002 to nearly 44% in 2012. 10,11 A temporary laddered nursing programme was introduced in 1982 in response to the rapid expansion of district health systems. Students received a diploma as technical nurses after a two-year course of study.…”