Professional Identity Formation: A Role for Patients as Mentors

Abstract

Purpose Medical education should foster professional identity formation, but there is much to be learned about how to support learners in developing their professional identity. This study examined the role that patients can play in supporting professional identity development during the University of British Columbia Interprofessional Health Mentors Program (HMP), a longitudinal preclinical elective in which patients, or their caregivers, act as mentors and educate students about their lived experience of a chronic condition or disability. Method The authors interviewed 18 medical residents in 2016, 3 to 4 years after they completed the HMP. Professional identity was explored by asking participants how the HMP had influenced their ideas about the ideal physician and the kind of doctor they aspire to become. The authors analyzed the data using the identify status paradigm as a conceptual framework. Results The authors identified 7 themes: patient as more than disease, patient as autonomous, patient as expert, doctor as partner, doctor as collaborator, self-aware doctor, and empathic doctor. They found firm commitments to patient partnership, interprofessional collaboration, and holistic care for patients rooted in the exploration of professional values that was prompted by patient mentors during HMP. Conclusions Patient mentors can help medical students begin to construct their professional identity during the preclinical period by supporting exploration of and commitment to the professional values that society expects of physicians.

Significados de mentoria na formação em saúde no Brasil: uma revisão integrativa

“…Para a compreensão da mentoria como um novo habitus na formação do profissional em saúde, outras revisões tornam-se importantes para maior análise e crítica de relações fundamentais: mentoria e identidade profissional 65 ; mentoria e desenvolvimento de carreira 66 ; mentoria e desenvolvimento do pensamento reflexivo e colaborativo 66,67 ; mentoria, estudante, paciente e prática interprofissional 68 ; e mentoria e desempenho acadêmico 69 . A esse convite de aprofundamento, agrega-se a necessidade de uma interlocução com um número maior de estudos internacionais que possam ampliar e consolidar os achados e as análises.…”

The power of proximity: Effects of a multidisciplinary fibroid clinic on inter-specialty perceptions and practice patterns

“…These methods are more common in the social sciences but have also been used in numerous medical publications [e.g. [ 23 , 24 ]] and were selected to best capture the complexity of subjects being discussed in the present study. This was performed by two authors and initially yielded 34 unique codes grouped into 4 distinct categories.…”

An evaluation of cascading mentorship as advocacy training in undergraduate medical education

“…By developing skills in the Health Advocate role, medical students learn to identify and address inequities in the social determinants of health and the manner in which these influence health outcomes in various populations [4]. Importantly, preclinical advocacy training provides the unique opportunity for students to develop their identity as advocates, unrestricted by the realities of clinical responsibilities that can overshadow patient care [5]. Nevertheless, advocacy training has historically been an underappreciated component of medical training [6].…”