Processes of Sub-Citizenship: Neoliberal Statecrafting ‘Citizens,’ ‘Non-Citizens,’ and Detainable ‘Others’

Abstract

Increasingly, scholars are exploring the politics of migration and the shifting terrain of citizenship from a critical mobilities perspective. To contribute to these discussions, in this paper, I explore how processes of sub-citizenship occur as nation-states craft immigration, citizenship, and border securitization policies and practices. I argue that complex and shifting processes of sub-citizenship largely occur through the nation-state’s production of ‘insiders’ (‘citizens’) and ‘outsiders’ (‘non-citizens’). As a nascent attempt to introduce sub-citizenship, I draw upon recent high-profile cases of family separation, abuse, and neglect experienced by children with ‘illegal migrant’ status in the United States and Australia. Under the international nation-state system and the neoliberal globalization paradigm, the border policing powers of nation-states are primed to expand and intensify processes of sub-citizenship. Those at lower levels of the sub-citizen hierarchy are at risk of experiencing various forms of state-led violence, including deportation, detention, and torture.

“I want to become part of the Australian community”: Challenging the marginalisation of women resettled as refugees in Australia – Findings from a photovoice project

“…Furthermore, women are denied voice in their representation, and “fixed formulations of the refugee woman” inform policy design (Wachter & Snyder, 2018). The government position is also shaped by neoliberalism, where the broader value of the refugee is their economic contribution to society (Reid, 2019; Rung, 2020). Hence, in recent years there has been an emphasis on employment in the AMEP curriculum (Scanlon Foundation Research Institute, 2019) and policy rhetoric about English language skills leading to economic integration (Tudge, 2018).…”

Symptoms of PTSD and Depression among Central American Immigrant Youth

“…Unaccompanied minors from Central America have been a frequent topic of discussion in the news since at least the so-called border crisis of 2014 [13,45], but with few exceptions, their voices are rarely heard. These exceptions include a few journalistic snippets, testimonios (first-person accounts) [46], interviews of detainees [47,48], or consideration of art they produce during detention [49]. Children have agency and their own way of processing and understanding their experiences and conditions [17], and the best way to understand their mental health outside of a clinical setting is through interviewing and assessing them directly.…”

“…Vocabulary related to mental health conditions used in the survey may have been unfamiliar to some of our respondents or understood differently in Spanish than in English [72]. There are cultural differences in interpretations and stigmas concerning mental health, which might have caused respondents to downplay, exaggerate, or altogether hide information or experiences [48,49]. Indeed, studies on mental health stigma and self-concealment have documented how some cultural elements in Latin communities make individuals wary of disclosing their mental health status or seeking out services [65,[73][74][75].…”

Building equitable health and social policy in Australia to improve immigrant health literacy

“…As migrants and refugees face compounded risks of social stratification, which produce health and wellbeing inequalities, a national approach to prioritise equity‐focused health and social policy is an essential element for improving immigrant health literacy in Australia, particularly for communities of non‐English speaking backgrounds 9 . This has been identified as a priority in the draft National Preventive Health Strategy 10 . Indeed, processes associated with immigration introduce numerous, and often complex intersections with multiple social, cultural and commercial determinants of health.…”

“…9 This has been identified as a priority in the draft National Preventive Health Strategy. 10 Indeed, processes associated with immigration introduce numerous, and often complex intersections with multiple social, cultural and commercial determinants of health. Australia's tiered approach to social benefits shapes who have access to health and wellbeing services and who does not.…”